Supreme Court Denies Overton’s Last Appeal; Florida Execution Set for 6 P.M.
Thirty-five years after Susan and Michael MacIvor were killed in their Tavernier home, the U.S. Supreme Court denied Thomas Mitchell Overton’s requests for a stay and for review on Thursday, leaving his execution set for 6 p.m.
4 minute read
RAIFORD — For 35 years, the family of Susan and Michael MacIvor had lived with the killings in the couple’s Tavernier home. On Thursday afternoon, they were hours from seeing the death sentence imposed in 1999 carried out. The U.S. Supreme Court denied Thomas Mitchell Overton’s application for a stay of execution and his petition for review, leaving Florida’s 6 p.m. execution at Florida State Prison on schedule.
The Court gave no explanation. The stay application, docketed as No. 26A686, had gone to Justice Clarence Thomas, the circuit justice for Florida, who referred it to the full Court. The Palm Beach Post reported the orders from the Court’s docket. The first read, “Application (26A686) for stay of execution of sentence of death presented to Justice Thomas and by him referred to the Court is denied,” and the companion order read, “The petition for a writ of certiorari is denied.”
What the denials do — and do not — decide
Overton, 71, has maintained his innocence. In his petition, he raised several claims, including a challenge to Florida’s clemency process. By declining to hear the case on Thursday, the Court left the Florida Supreme Court’s November 13 decision in effect and reached no conclusion on the merits of Overton’s claims. The denial of a stay removed the last judicial barrier to the execution and left the existing findings on guilt undisturbed.
Gov. Ron DeSantis signed the death warrant on October 21, setting the execution for 6 p.m. on Thursday, November 19, at Florida State Prison near Raiford. Overton was sentenced to death in 1999 for the 1991 murders of Susan “Missy” MacIvor, a Monroe County teacher who was eight months pregnant, and her husband, Michael MacIvor.
The state-court end of the road
The Florida Supreme Court disposed of Overton’s remaining state-court challenges on November 13 in an opinion by Justice John Tanenbaum (SC2026-1724 and SC2026-1725). Justice Jorge Labarga concurred in the result. The court affirmed the summary denial of Overton’s third successive postconviction motion, denied his petition for habeas corpus and refused a stay. It ordered its mandate to issue immediately, with no rehearing. The court held that public-records demands in a capital case must be tied to a cognizable claim and are “not tools by which to conduct a fishing expedition”. It explained that Florida law requires newly discovered evidence for a freestanding claim of actual innocence and held that the kind of clemency challenge Overton brought was not cognizable. The court also reaffirmed the constitutionality of Florida’s capital sentencing scheme.
Overton’s lawyers filed the federal petition on November 14. The state filed its response, and a reply followed. The case remained with the justices through Thursday afternoon, when the orders appeared on the docket.
What happens at 6 p.m.
If the execution goes ahead as scheduled, it will be Florida’s 20th of 2026, surpassing the 19 carried out in 2025. The Palm Beach Post reported those figures against the Department of Corrections’ tally, and this desk reported them in its morning story. Every court Overton asked to intervene has now answered. None did. Only the Department of Corrections can confirm whether the execution has taken place. This story will be updated when the department confirms the outcome.
More of this desk’s coverage is on the State hub and in the State archive. This morning’s account of the scheduled execution and the Florida Supreme Court’s ruling is here, and the desk’s earlier coverage of the U.S. Supreme Court’s November orders is here.
Sources & notes
- U.S. Supreme Court docket, Overton v. Florida, application No. 26A686 and companion certiorari petition — stay application filed November 14, 2026; denials of the stay application and of certiorari on November 19, 2026, in the docket language quoted above as reported from the Court’s record by the Palm Beach Post (live updates, November 19, 2026, 2:13 p.m. ET entry). The Associated Press likewise reported Thursday that the Court denied a final appeal in the Florida case. A certiorari denial is not a merits ruling; the story states it as such.
- Florida Supreme Court opinion, November 13, 2026 (SC2026-1724 / SC2026-1725) — read in full by this desk for this morning’s story: summary denial affirmed, habeas and stay denied, mandate immediate.
- Death warrant signed by Gov. Ron DeSantis, October 21, 2026, and the desk’s verified record: execution scheduled Thursday, November 19, 2026, 6:00 p.m., Florida State Prison near Raiford; sentence imposed in 1999 for the 1991 Tavernier murders of Susan and Michael MacIvor.
- Execution count (a 20th execution of 2026, passing 2025’s 19) as reported by the Palm Beach Post against the Florida Department of Corrections count, carried from this desk’s November 19 morning story and attributed in the text. The execution’s outcome is not asserted here; it awaits the department’s confirmation.
Photo: Orange County Courthouse, file photograph reused from Citizen coverage. Photo: Rivera, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank

