Local Government

Orange County Commissioners Deny Avalon Road Agricultural Enclave: Toll Brothers’ 39-Acre Bid Fails 6-0

After twelve residents of the Lake Avalon Rural Settlement addressed the board on Nov. 10, Orange County commissioners voted 6-0 to deny Toll Brothers' bid to certify 39.23 acres on Avalon Road as an agricultural enclave.

5 minute read

ShareFacebookX

Twelve residents of the Lake Avalon Rural Settlement addressed the Orange County Board of County Commissioners on November 10 with 39.23 acres on Avalon Road in the balance. When the hearing ended, the board had voted 6-0 to deny Toll Brothers’ request to certify the land as an agricultural enclave — a designation that would have let the parcel be developed for housing at the density of its neighbors, whatever the county’s own map says.

For the families who live along Avalon Road, just north of Horizon West, the question that reached county commissioners looked narrow and technical on paper: does one parcel of farmland meet the tests Florida law sets for an agricultural enclave? The county’s answer, recorded in the Board’s official legislative file, was no. The land at 5477 Avalon Road stays what it is — a single uncertified parcel inside the Lake Avalon Rural Settlement — while county staff prepare the written decision, in detailed findings of fact and conclusions of law, that will spell out the board’s reasoning.

The vote

The hearing came before the Board of County Commissioners on Tuesday, November 10, 2026, under legislative file 26-1297, “Toll Brothers, Avalon Road Agricultural Enclave Certification; District 1.” According to the file maintained by the Orange County Comptroller as Clerk of the Board, twelve people addressed the commissioners: Logan Opsahl, who also presented an exhibit logged in the record, along with Crystal Seidle, Maria Casanova-Baker, Kathy Sheerin, Suzanne Arnold, Kelly Dunn, Arthur Slowe, Heather Thompson, Elizabeth Oberdick, Laurie Forrester, Danise Martinez and Dana Hutchison.

Commissioner Nicole Wilson, whose District 1 covers the property, made the motion, and Commissioner Maribel Gomez Cordero seconded it. As recorded in the clerk’s file, the motion took three steps: it made a finding that the request does not comply with the requirements of Section 163.3162(4)(a), Florida Statutes; it denied certification of the parcel generally known as 5477 Avalon Road as an agricultural enclave under Section 163.3162(4); and it directed staff to prepare the written decision reflecting the denial, including the detailed findings of fact and conclusions of law required by Section 163.3162(4)(d). The motion carried 6-0, with Mayor Jerry L. Demings and Commissioners Wilson, Mike Crabb, Gomez Cordero, Kelly Martinez Semrad and Michael Scott voting aye. Commissioner Mayra Uribe was absent.

What was asked, and what certification would have meant

In the phrasing of the county’s own file, the request sought “to certify one parcel totaling 39.23 acres within the Lake Avalon Rural Settlement known as 5477 Avalon Road as an Agricultural Enclave pursuant to Florida Statutes Section 163.3162 and as defined by Florida Statutes 163.3164.” Per the file, the parcel sits north of McKinney Road and south of Phil C Peters Road, on the east side of Avalon Road, east of Alps Street, just north of Horizon West.

An agricultural enclave, as Orange County explains on its Engage Orange County hearing page, is a designation created by Florida law — the county identifies the governing measure as Senate Bill 686 — for certain undeveloped agricultural land that meets statutory requirements on location, ownership, agricultural use, surrounding development, availability of public services and acreage. Certification would not have approved a subdivision, a site plan or any construction. What it would have changed was the threshold for what could follow: the owner could subsequently submit applications for residential development, and, in the county’s words, state law would require the proposed residential use to be treated as allowed even if it differs from the property’s current future land use designation or zoning, at a density equivalent to one or more adjacent properties. Detailed development plans, engineering reviews and permits would still have been required.

Orange County did not initiate the request, and it was not free to ignore it. Under Florida law, the county’s page states, the county must review such an application, prepare a written report evaluating whether it satisfies the statutory criteria and hold a public hearing before the Board — and if commissioners fail to approve or deny the application within 90 days of receiving it, the law requires the parcels to be certified automatically. The November 10 hearing was that decision point.

What happens now

As a vote, the denial is final; as a record, the paperwork is not finished. The Board directed staff to prepare the written decision setting out the findings of fact and conclusions of law behind the finding of non-compliance with Section 163.3162(4)(a). When this desk checked the legislative file on November 22, that written decision had not been posted among the file’s attachments, which so far hold the hearing request, the staff memorandum and report, the hearing presentation and the speaker’s exhibit and submittal. This desk will report the written decision’s specific findings once the county posts them. On the Comptroller’s Legistar record, draft minutes of the November 10 meeting are posted, while the meeting’s approved minutes are not yet available there.

The Avalon Road vote is one of two rural-boundary fights Orange County has lost or won in the same fortnight: separately, a judge has voided the county’s rural-boundary ordinance in the Lake Pickett case, in coverage carried on this desk’s Local Government archive — see Judge Voids Orange County’s Rural-Boundary Ordinance in the Lake Pickett Sustanee Case. Ahead of the commission is its next regular meeting on December 1, whose agenda — including hearings on the tourist tax, the I-Drive redevelopment plan and a temporary data-center moratorium — is previewed in Orange County Commissioners Meeting Agenda for December 1: Tourist Tax, I-Drive and Data Centers. Days later, on December 8, the board that voted on Avalon Road gives way, in part, when the mayor-elect and five commissioners take the oath of office, as this desk reported in Orange County Oath of Office December 8.

Sources & notes

Every fact in this article is traced to the official record checked on November 22, 2026: (1) Orange County Comptroller, Clerk of the Board, Legistar legislative file 26-1297 (Toll Brothers, Avalon Road Agricultural Enclave Certification; District 1) — the consideration text (one parcel, 39.23 acres, Lake Avalon Rural Settlement, location description), the recorded action of November 10, 2026 (motion by Commissioner Wilson, seconded by Commissioner Gomez Cordero; finding under Section 163.3162(4)(a); denial under Section 163.3162(4); direction to staff to prepare the written decision under Section 163.3162(4)(d)), the vote (6 aye, 0 nay, 1 absent — Commissioner Uribe), the list of persons who addressed the Board, and the file’s six attachments, none of which is the written decision as of this check; (2) Engage Orange County (Orange County Government, ocfl.net), “Avalon Road Agricultural Enclave Public Hearing” — the county’s statement that at the November 10, 2026 public hearing the Board voted to deny the request, its description of the property at 5477 Avalon Road in District 1, its explanation of agricultural-enclave certification and its effects, the 90-day statutory rule, and its identification of Senate Bill 686 as the governing measure. The November 10 meeting’s minutes are posted on Legistar as draft minutes; the meeting record’s “Approved Minutes” field reads “Not available” as of this check, and this article relies on the file’s recorded action and the county’s hearing page rather than on the draft minutes. No figure in this article comes from secondary reporting.

Featured photograph: Florida Cracker cattle on pasture at the St. Cloud Canal, Osceola County — a file photograph of Central Florida ranch land, not the Avalon Road parcel. Photograph by Benoît Prieur, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons; house photo grade applied (crop only, no subject altered).

Filed under · · · · ·

Editor’s Picks

  1. 1NewsEpic Universe Faces Its First Holiday Season
  2. 2ReviewsThe 10 Best Coffee Shops in Orlando
  3. 3TourismMagic Kingdom
  4. 4Top BusinessesHaan Coffee: Mills 50’s Korean-Inflected Roaster Tops Orlando Coffee
  5. 5ReviewsThe 10 Best Attractions & Things To Do in Orlando

Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank

A. B. Newton

Orlando Citizen local government and taxes reporter. Covers the county commissions, Orlando City Council, property tax and budgets from agendas, adopted minutes and official releases — every figure traced to the document it came from.