Local GovernmentNews

Judge Voids Orange County’s Rural-Boundary Ordinance in the Lake Pickett Sustanee Case

Circuit Judge Tanya Davis Wilson sided with the Lake Pickett landowners on November 17, voiding Orange County’s rural-boundary ordinance and a related plan amendment under state law, while the proposed Sustanee development still needs a county land-use map change.

3 minute read

ShareFacebookX

ORLANDO — For nearly two years, landowners seeking to put roughly 1,800 single-family homes on ranchland in east Orange County have been at odds with the voters and commissioners who drew a harder line against development. At stake was who could decide what became of 1,317 acres at the county’s rural edge. The landowners argued that the state had already taken that power away from the county. On Tuesday, a circuit judge ruled that state law governed and that the county’s ordinance was void as if it had never been adopted.

In a Final Judgment signed November 17, 2026, Circuit Judge Tanya Davis Wilson granted summary judgment to Lake Pickett North LLC, Rolling R Ranch Ltd and Mary Rybolt Lamar and denied Orange County’s cross-motion for summary judgment in Lake Pickett North LLC et al. v. Orange County Florida, Case No. 2025-CA-007326-O in the Circuit Court of the Ninth Judicial Circuit. She declared Orange County Ordinance No. 2025-13 and Comprehensive Plan Amendment 2024-2-B-CP-3 “null and void ab initio” under section 28(1) of chapter 2025-190, Laws of Florida, the provision of the 2025 state law known as SB 180 on which the landowners had based their challenge.

The proposed Sustanee rural planned development would put those homes east of the urban edge, in the Lake Pickett area. It needed a change to the county’s Comprehensive Plan land-use map. According to the judgment, the Board of County Commissioners denied that change at a transmittal hearing on January 23, 2024. The county later adopted the ordinance and plan amendment the landowners challenged, and the landowners sued on July 31, 2025. They moved for summary judgment on June 25, 2026, and the county filed its cross-motion on July 2, 2026. The two sides argued their motions at a hearing on October 19, 2026.

Judge Wilson granted the plaintiffs’ motion on Count I, denied the county’s cross-motion and declared both the ordinance and the amendment void from the beginning. She denied every other request for relief in the complaint and retained jurisdiction to decide whether the landowners are entitled to attorney’s fees and costs and, if so, how much. The clerk’s record lists the case as closed.

Orange County had asked Judge Wilson to rule in its favor on the same papers. The judgment does not address an appeal, and no notice of appeal appeared on the docket when the Citizen reviewed it Saturday morning. The clerk’s record lists a companion Lake Pickett case before Circuit Judge Brian Sandor as on appeal. The county’s rural-boundary framework is thus being tested in more than one courtroom. Unless Tuesday’s judgment is appealed and reversed, the ordinance that framework rested on in this case is void.

Sustanee still needs the map change the commissioners denied in 2024. The judgment issued no development order, and the project must still go through the county’s process, which now proceeds without Ordinance No. 2025-13. In December, the incoming county administration inherits the question of what terms would govern the conversion of the ranchland to housing and who would set them: Tallahassee, the county or the landowners. The Citizen’s account of what changes on day one for the mayor-elect is here.

The Citizen’s Court Watch desk follows the metro’s dockets daily. Its earlier coverage of the county’s litigation includes the downtown venues’ after-midnight fees appeal and the Ortiz wrongful-death case. This story will be updated if a notice of appeal or a fee motion is filed.

Sources & notes: Final Judgment, Lake Pickett North LLC et al. v. Orange County Florida, No. 2025-CA-007326-O (Fla. 9th Cir. Ct. Nov. 17, 2026), read in full on the Orange County Clerk’s myEClerk record on November 21, 2026, including the docket (filed July 31, 2025; plaintiffs’ summary-judgment motion June 25, 2026; county cross-motion July 2, 2026; hearing October 19, 2026). The county’s position is stated from its cross-motion as recorded in the judgment; no appeal was on the docket at the time of reading.

Filed under · · · · ·

Editor’s Picks

  1. 1NewsEpic Universe Faces Its First Holiday Season
  2. 2ReviewsThe 10 Best Coffee Shops in Orlando
  3. 3TourismMagic Kingdom
  4. 4Top BusinessesHaan Coffee: Mills 50’s Korean-Inflected Roaster Tops Orlando Coffee
  5. 5ReviewsThe 10 Best Attractions & Things To Do in Orlando

Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank

Ellis Geiger

Orlando Citizen general-assignment reporter for city and county news — the commissions, the civic institutions and the county's small towns, reported from the record.