Colonialtown Orlando: Two Neighbourhoods, One Historic District and the Brick Streets Between
Divided by Colonial Drive, Orlando's Colonialtown pairs two separate neighborhoods under one name — one governed by standard city permits, the other guarded by a historic preservation board.
3 minute read
For a homeowner in Colonialtown South, even the most modest exterior project — a new fence, an addition, a changed window — begins not in the aisles of a hardware store, but before a municipal board. That extra step is the price, and as many residents see it, the entire point, of buying into one of Orlando’s local historic districts. Here, the bungalows and brick streets that draw buyers in the first place are bound by a bargain: no future owner may quietly erase them. Walk a few blocks north across Colonial Drive, however, and an almost identical streetscape carries no such obligation.
Under one familiar name, Colonialtown operates as two distinct regulatory worlds. Officially, the City of Orlando recognizes Colonialtown North and Colonialtown South as separate neighborhoods split by Colonial Drive. According to the city, the area took shape over roughly six decades, beginning when its earliest subdivision was platted in 1883 and accelerating with significant further development from 1913. Yet only Colonialtown South holds local historic district status, a designation granted in 2000. South of the divide, certain exterior alterations, additions, new construction, relocations and demolitions may require a Certificate of Appropriateness from Orlando’s Historic Preservation Board; north of it, where no historic district exists, exterior work proceeds through normal permitting.
Where the lines run
The preservation rules govern a compact pocket of 1920s Arts & Crafts homes and brick streets shaded by live oaks, lying generally south of Hillcrest Street, north of East Robinson Street, east of Shine Avenue and west of Hampton Street. That district sits inside a broader Colonialtown footprint stretching from East Robinson Street north to Corrine Drive, and from North Mills Avenue east to North Bumby Avenue. In a landscape otherwise defined by tightly spaced houses, Colonialtown Square Park on North Fern Creek Avenue serves as the residential blocks’ shared common — a pocket of open space, gardens and mature shade trees.
The corridor at its edge
For daily commerce, both halves lean on Mills 50, the Orlando Main Street district anchored by the intersection of Mills Avenue and Colonial Drive, or State Road 50, lined with locally owned businesses and international dining. Together they strike a familiar Orlando balance: an artery lively enough to be useful, beside side streets quiet enough to leave the traffic behind. Still, the dividing highway remains decisive. In the South, a preservation board stands deliberately between the streetscape as it is and a future owner’s hurry to remake it — a distinction prospective buyers either grasp before closing on a house, or discover the first time they step up to the permit counter.
More from the Colonialtown hub: the Citizen’s neighbourhood record, Colonialtown, Explained; Colonialtown’s Green Rim, its parks in full; and Walking the Colonialtown South Historic District.
Sources & notes
Two-neighbourhood structure, the South’s 2000 historic designation, the 1883 plat / 1913 development history as stated by the City of Orlando, Certificate of Appropriateness requirements, Colonialtown Square Park on North Fern Creek Avenue, and the Mills 50 relationship: Park Life Orlando’s Colonialtown community guide, summarising City of Orlando records, checked Nov. 17, 2026. District boundaries (Hillcrest / East Robinson / Shine / Hampton) and the North’s non-district status: Bright Florida Homes’ Mills 50 / Colonialtown guide and Homes.com’s Colonialtown South guide, both checked Nov. 17. No home-price figure is asserted in this spotlight. Featured image: file image from related Citizen Colonialtown coverage; see that post for its credit.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank


