Orlando Thanksgiving Pie Orders 2026: Sister Honey’s Slots, the Nov. 20 Four Seasons Deadline and What’s Closed
For the Orlando dinner guest who promised to bring dessert, time is running short: Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream closed its pie book Nov. 14, Sister Honey's sells strictly by online slot, and the Four Seasons window shuts Friday, Nov. 20.
3 minute read
At almost every Thanksgiving table in Orlando, someone volunteered weeks ago to bring the pie — only to realize, right around now, that volunteering was the easy part. For the home guest hoping a professional kitchen might quietly take over the job, salvation depends less on holiday goodwill than on the unforgiving arithmetic of bakery calendars. Across the city, the rules vary sharply: one of Orlando’s most decorated pie shops books its holiday orders strictly by online slot rather than by a cutoff date, then locks its doors for Thanksgiving week altogether. What follows is the state of the city’s pie orders, bakery by bakery, traced directly to each shop’s published terms or to this paper’s verified reporting.
The deadline table: Sister Honey’s (247 E. Michigan St.) — Thanksgiving orders opened Friday, Nov. 6, online only, exclusively for its Pumpkin Pecan Streusel Pie; once the order slots fill, no further orders are accepted, and no phone or walk-in holiday orders are taken; the bakery is closed Nov. 26–30 and reopens Dec. 1. Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream — pie orders closed Nov. 14 (Citizen record). Four Seasons Orlando — holiday orders, with pies included in its Thanksgiving offering, close Friday, Nov. 20 (Citizen record). Bakery 1908 — No. 1 in the Citizen’s Best Bakeries ranking (Net Score 93.4); no Thanksgiving order deadline was published on the channels checked today, so none is asserted here — ask the bakery directly.
The slot, not the date: Sister Honey’s
If one document captures the discipline of buying a Thanksgiving pie in Orlando this year, it is the notice Sister Honey’s posted on Oct. 22. The shop on East Michigan Street pared its holiday offering down to a single dessert, the Pumpkin Pecan Streusel Pie, sold strictly through its online ordering system. During Thanksgiving week, the kitchen processes only pre-orders for that pie, and when the slots are gone, the notice states plainly, they are gone. For a household still empty-handed, the website holds the entire verdict: if an opening remains, it will appear there, and if none does, a telephone call will not pry one loose. From Thanksgiving Day, Nov. 26, through Nov. 30, the bakery is closed — leaving no possibility of a last-minute walk-in rescue.
What is already closed, and what closes Friday
Elsewhere across the city, the window is narrowing fast, with two early thresholds on this list already behind us or governed by capacity. Pie orders at Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream shut on Nov. 14, part of the same early wave of cutoffs that closed the first Thanksgiving to-go menus tracked by this paper on Monday. That leaves Four Seasons Orlando as the clear live option with a firm calendar date: its holiday ordering — which includes the resort’s pies, according to Orlando Magazine’s account of the offering — remains open until Friday, Nov. 20, matching the resort’s to-go meal cutoff in the Citizen’s deadline record. Once Friday passes, the latecomer is left with bakeries such as top-ranked Bakery 1908 that post no formal cutoff at all — an absence of a published deadline that should never be mistaken for an endless supply of pies, leaving late shoppers to call ahead or start reaching for a mixing bowl.
More from the Audubon Park hub: the full ranking behind the Bakery 1908 line, Best Bakeries in Orlando; the companion deadline asset for the rest of the meal, Thanksgiving to-go in Orlando, ranked by deadline; and this morning’s Thanksgiving grocery hours guide for the Wednesday shop that now includes the flour.
Sources & notes
Sister Honey’s (247 E. Michigan St.): Thanksgiving notice dated Oct. 22, 2026 — online-only orders from Fri Nov. 6, Pumpkin Pecan Streusel Pie, slots-close rule, no phone/walk-in holiday orders, closed Nov. 26–30, reopening Dec. 1 — as carried on the bakery’s notice and checked Nov. 17, 2026. Kelly’s pie-order close (Nov. 14) and the Four Seasons order window (Oct. 9–Nov. 20): the Citizen’s own verified Thanksgiving to-go record, Nov. 15–16, 2026, linked above; Four Seasons pies as part of the holiday offering: Orlando Magazine’s Nov. 3, 2026 Thanksgiving guide, checked Nov. 17. Bakery 1908’s No. 1 position and Net Score (93.4): the Citizen’s Best Bakeries ranking data, as stated in today’s SEO brief — and the absence of a published Bakery 1908 Thanksgiving deadline on today’s checks is stated as an absence, not filled. Featured image: file image from related Citizen Thanksgiving coverage; see that post for its credit.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank


