Kissimmee Pizza Night: Ranked Pienezza vs. Downtown’s Broadway Pizza Bar
One is a family-run New York shop at The Loop with a 91.9 Net Score. The other is Broadway's pie-and-a-patio living room. Which Kissimmee pizza night is yours?
3 minute read
Kissimmee has two pizza answers, and they are not in competition — they are in different moods. One is a family-run New York-style shop up at The Loop that our rankings rate among the best pies in the entire Orlando region. The other is downtown’s pie-and-a-patio living room on Broadway. A proper Kissimmee pizza night means knowing which mood you are in. Both are on our Kissimmee hub; here is the honest comparison.
The ranked one: Pienezza Pizza
Pienezza Pizza, at 3236 N. John Young Parkway in The Loop shopping district, holds the No. 7 spot in our Best Pizza in Orlando rankings with a Net Score of 91.9 — a score that puts a Kissimmee strip-center pizzeria ahead of most of Orlando’s fashionable rooms. The family’s pitch is Brooklyn tradition, and the menu shows its work: thin and crispy New York pies, a deep-dish Sicilian, a Grandma pie, specialty builds like the Hey Brooklyn and the Crazy Margherita, plus stromboli, garlic knots — including everything-bagel knots — and the supporting cast of salads and sandwiches a real neighborhood pizzeria carries.
What the score is measuring is discipline. NY-style pizza is a narrow target — a crust that is thin but structured, crisp at the rim, with sauce and cheese in balance — and Pienezza hits it with the consistency that turns first-timers into regulars. The Loop location, next to the cinema, makes it the area’s easiest dinner-and-a-movie play: pie first, film second, and a box for the ride home if the table ordered with ambition. Note the pattern before you plan around it: the shop keeps lunch-and-dinner hours Monday through Saturday and rests on Sunday, per its published hours. This is a family shop, not a franchise, and it keeps family-shop hours.
The downtown one: Broadway Pizza Bar
Downtown, Broadway Pizza Bar at 403 Broadway plays the other essential role: the neighborhood’s pizza bar. New York-style pies again — this is Florida, the transplants set the standard — with specialty builds including a Buffalo chicken pizza and a pesto pie, plus wings, salads and a cheesecake that regulars insist you order. The differences are setting and tempo. Broadway has the full bar, the outdoor patio on the main street, and the live-music, linger-a-while energy of downtown Kissimmee at night. It is where a lakefront afternoon turns into dinner without anyone changing clothes or moving the car far.
The verdict, by occasion
Pizza as the destination — the best crust you can get in Kissimmee, ranked and verified: Pienezza. Pizza as the evening — patio, drinks, downtown around you: Broadway Pizza Bar. Families doing The Loop’s shops and cinema will land at Pienezza without trying; couples walking off a Lakefront Park sunset belong on Broadway. Both appear in our broader where to eat in Kissimmee roundup, and both are pinned on the Orlando Top Spots Map.
And a word for the slice test, because both kitchens pass it differently. Pienezza’s thin-and-crispy pie eats like a New York slice should — foldable, structured, the rim worth eating after the point is gone. Broadway’s pies are built for the table rather than the fold: specialty toppings, a bar within reach, a patio going past dark. Neither is a compromise version of the other. Kissimmee simply has two pizza places that know what they are, which puts it ahead of most suburbs in Florida and a fair few neighborhoods in New York.
The larger point is worth making: Kissimmee’s food scene rewards specifics. Its best barbecue is downtown, its best Mexican is on Vine Street, and its best pizza requires choosing between a Loop storefront and a Broadway patio. That is a real dining city wearing a tourist corridor’s clothes — and pizza night is the cheapest way to prove it to yourself.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Related Stories
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank