The 10 Best Private Schools in Orlando
Orlando's 10 best private schools, ranked by Net Score from public ratings across the metro: Bishop Moore Catholic High School leads at 77.6.
5 minute read
Choosing a private school is the biggest education decision most Orlando families make, and the options do not sit still long enough to compare easily. This ranking scores private K-12 schools across the Orlando metro — Orange, Seminole and Osceola counties — with all levels ranked together, from elementary-only academies to a high-school-only campus, and multi-campus schools scored individually, campus by campus. We scored 30 campuses and 21 clear our evidence bar; a College Park Catholic high school, Bishop Moore, takes No. 1 with a Net Score of 77.6.
How we rank: every business is ordered by its Net Score (0–100), which blends its public ratings from Google, TripAdvisor, Yelp and the other review sources we could retrieve — weighted by review volume, then adjusted so a handful of five-star reviews can’t outrank a proven track record (Bayesian shrinkage, m = 200, disclosed in our methodology). A business needs at least 25 public reviews to be ranked. Scores compare only within this category. Ratings retrieved November 15, 2026. Our Net Score blends the public star ratings we could retrieve (Google, and Yelp where listed). Niche grades are shown alongside each school as context — an editorial rating on its own scale, not blended into the Net Score. GreatSchools does not publish ratings for most private schools in this field, so it appears only where it exists.
1. Bishop Moore Catholic High School — Net Score 77.6 (College Park)

🏆 Winner feature: Read our full profile of Bishop Moore Catholic High School — why it won, what to try, and the badge to share.
Blended 4.68★ from 201 reviews — Google 4.68★ (201).
Context: Niche A-.
Get: The Catholic high-school experience: the school’s mission statement puts it plainly — driven by Catholic faith, striving for excellence in all it does. This is the ranking’s high-school-only entry, so no elementary or middle grades share the campus.
Local detail: At 3901 Edgewater Drive in College Park, with a school day that runs 7:30 a.m. to 3:30 p.m. on weekdays, per its listing.
2. Trinity Preparatory School — Net Score 76.1 (Winter Park)
Blended 4.81★ from 135 reviews — Google 4.81★ (135).
Context: Niche A+.
Get: Breadth: its listing claims the widest course selection in Central Florida, with AP and Honors classes, 59 sports teams across 25 sports, and more than 60 fine arts electives — plus a college counseling department it credits with four times the national average of Ivy League–plus acceptances.
Local detail: Grades 6–12 only, on its own lane — 5700 Trinity Prep Lane — in Winter Park; an Episcopal-affiliated independent school, per the compile record.
3. The Christ School — Net Score 73.6 (Downtown Orlando)
Blended 4.96★ from 83 reviews — Google 4.96★ (83).
Context: Niche A+.
Get: An individualized K–8 experience: the school partners with families on academic excellence, and its listing materials point to a STEAM Lab for hands-on building and design, an exploratory science curriculum, and a Bridge program serving students with dyslexia.
Local detail: Downtown at 106 E Church Street, where students begin each day in Chapel — the spiritual strand of a program its listing describes as educating students academically, physically, spiritually and socially.
4. Windermere Preparatory School — Net Score 73.1 (Windermere)
Blended 4.71★ from 101 reviews — Google 4.71★ (101).
Context: Niche A+.
Get: The full span in one place: PK3 through Grade 12 at what its listing bills as Central Florida’s leading international school — and the top ten’s only boarding option, with boarding for Grades 7–12.
Local detail: At 6189 Winter Garden Vineland Road in Windermere, the ranking’s southwest-metro campus.
5. Holy Family Catholic School — Net Score 72.3 (Dr. Phillips)
Blended 4.94★ from 70 reviews — Google 4.94★ (70).
Context: Niche B+.
Get: A Catholic K–8 built around faith and care: its stated mission pairs the Gospel message with a supportive, caring learning environment and a push for academic excellence — faith, knowledge and love are its own three words for the goal.
Local detail: In the Dr. Phillips area at 5129 S Apopka Vineland Road; its Places record is a combined church-and-school listing, so some of the record’s activity reflects the parish alongside the school.
6. Park Maitland School — Net Score 71.2 (Maitland)
Blended 4.97★ from 58 reviews — Google 4.97★ (58).
Context: Niche A+.
Get: Whole-child schooling for preschool through eighth grade: its listing describes an emphasis on academic, social, emotional and physical development, designed for children whose abilities range from high average to gifted, balancing character with academic excellence.
Local detail: The main Maitland campus at 1450 S Orlando Avenue — the school’s separate Winter Park campus, Park Maitland South, was scored on its own record in this ranking.
7. Orlando Christian Prep — Net Score 70.9 (Azalea Park)
Blended 4.60★ from 81 reviews — Google 4.6★ (81).
Context: Niche A-.
Get: A K–12 Christian program that pairs challenging academics with competitive fine arts and award-winning athletics — its listing’s own trio — in an environment it describes as safe and oriented to spiritual as well as academic development.
Local detail: In Azalea Park at 500 S Semoran Boulevard, serving the full K–12 span on one campus.
8. St. James Cathedral School — Net Score 69.4 (Downtown Orlando)
Blended 4.85★ from 47 reviews — Google 4.85★ (47).
Get: A Pre-K through 8th Grade Catholic education with history: dedicated to academic excellence and educational ministry since 1928, under the philosophy “Come to Learn. Leave to Serve.”, with tailored teacher-to-student ratios and a child-centered curriculum.
Local detail: In the heart of downtown Orlando at 505 E Ridgewood Street, just steps from Lake Eola, per its listing.
9. Lake Mary Preparatory School — Net Score 69.3 (Lake Mary)
Blended 4.76★ from 50 reviews — Google 4.76★ (50).
Context: Niche A+.
Get: Personal attention at PreK–12 scale: its listing puts the school at 615 students with an 8:1 student-teacher ratio, balancing a robust, active campus with individualized attention.
Local detail: At 650 Rantoul Lane in Lake Mary, the northernmost campus in the top ten.
10. Gotlib Jewish Academy — Net Score 68.7 (Maitland)
Blended 4.77★ from 44 reviews — Google 4.77★ (44).
Get: A Jewish community day school where academic excellence and Jewish values shape the program: founded in 1977, it describes grounding students in Jewish values and social-emotional development to build identity, confidence and resilience.
Local detail: In Maitland at 851 N Maitland Avenue, serving elementary grades (K–5) — and filed under its current name: it was formerly the Jewish Academy of Orlando.
Part of Orlando Citizen’s Top Businesses in Orlando series. Net Scores are recalculated from fresh public review data each edition.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
The Winner & More Rankings
- Read the Winner FeatureBishop Moore Catholic High School, profiled
- On the MapSee Bishop Moore Catholic High School on the Top Spots map
- The NeighborhoodCollege Park — the area guide
- More RankingsBest Public K-12 Schools in Orlando, ranked by score
- More RankingsThe best Craft Breweries in Orlando — the full list
- More RankingsOrlando’s best Cocktail Bars, ranked
- The Full IndexAll 30 Top Businesses in Orlando rankings
- Browse by AreaOrlando by neighborhood — every area guide
For businesses
Own a restaurant or venue?
You can ask Orlando Citizen to review it. Asking never buys a verdict and never guarantees coverage — but every request is read by an editor. Request a review.
About the byline
Sofia Marchetti
Food & Dining reporter for Orlando Citizen. Covers restaurant openings, closings and DBPR inspection results, tied to the Top Businesses rankings.
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank


