ReviewsTop Businesses

The 10 Best Caterers in Orlando

Orlando's 10 best caterers, ranked by real review data — Longwood's Catered Delight holds a perfect score to lead 21.

4 minute read

ShareFacebookX

Catering is the ranking Orlando’s review platforms make hardest to build honestly: much of the industry’s review pool sits on wedding platforms this methodology does not score, and several of the metro’s best-known names — Puff ‘n Stuff among them — return no retrievable rating-and-count pair on any scored source, so they do not appear here at all. What does appear is what the scored data supports: 31 catering businesses compiled across the metro, 21 clearing our 25-review evidence bar, ordered by the same Net Score as every other list in this series.

How we rank: every business is ordered by its Net Score (0–100), which blends its public ratings from Google, TripAdvisor, Yelp and the other review sources we could retrieve — weighted by review volume, then adjusted so a handful of five-star reviews can’t outrank a proven track record (Bayesian shrinkage, m = 200, disclosed in our methodology). A business needs at least 25 public reviews to be ranked. Scores compare only within this category. Ratings retrieved November 16, 2026.

1. Catered Delight — Net Score 95.0 (Longwood)

Orlando Citizen Best Caterers 2026 award badge
Orlando Citizen Award — Best Caterers 2026Awarded to Catered Delight, No. 1 in this ranking.

Blended 5.00★ from 103 reviews — Google 5.0★ (103).

A Longwood caterer at 255 S Ronald Reagan Blvd whose retrieved review text was too thin to distill responsibly. Its score needs no embellishment: a Google-review aggregate of 5.0★ across 103 reviews (via Restaurantji — no places record was retrievable) is a perfect rating on a real base, and the volume adjustment still leaves it first in the category.

2. Arthur’s Catering and Events — Net Score 94.7 (Altamonte Springs)

Blended 4.92★ from 136 reviews — Google 4.92★ (136).

An Altamonte Springs caterer at 860 Sunshine Ln whose scored-source review text was too thin to distill responsibly — and the strongest primary-source record in this category: a places-verified 4.92★ across 136 Google reviews. Its unscored wedding-platform reviews, which this methodology does not count, consistently praise food quality and day-of coordination.

3. Top Private Chef — Net Score 94.2 (Thornton Park / Lake Eola)

Blended 5.00★ from 60 reviews — Google 5.0★ (60).

A Thornton Park private-chef and catering service at 619 Eola Dr whose retrieved review text was thin: the one featured review we retrieved describes a last-minute rescue of a birthday dinner, praising the food and the in-home service. It ranks on a Google-review aggregate of 5.0★ across 60 reviews.

4. Gourmet Catering — Net Score 94.0 (Orlando)

Blended 5.00★ from 51 reviews — Google 5.0★ (51).

An Orlando caterer at 1636 Prospect Ave whose retrieved review text was too thin to distill responsibly; it ranks on a Google-review aggregate of 5.0★ across 51 reviews — a perfect rating the shrinkage adjustment discounts for its modest base, holding it fourth.

5. Park Ave VIP Catering — Net Score 93.8 (East Orlando)

Blended 5.00★ from 43 reviews — Google 5.0★ (43).

An east Orlando caterer at 2400 N Forsyth Rd whose retrieved review text was thin: the one featured review we retrieved praises food that was delicious, fresh and beautifully presented, professional and attentive staff, and fair pricing. It ranks on a Google-review aggregate of 5.0★ across 43 reviews.

6. Uncommon Catering & Eatery — Net Score 93.6 (Conway / Curry Ford)

Blended 5.00★ from 34 reviews — Google 5.0★ (34).

A Conway caterer-and-eatery at 2942 Curry Ford Rd whose retrieved review text was too thin to distill responsibly; its places-verified 5.0★ across 34 Google reviews is one of only three primary-source records in this top 10 — a perfect score on a small base, ranked accordingly.

7. Table Top Catering — Net Score 93.5 (South Orlando)

Blended 4.80★ from 145 reviews — Google 4.8★ (145).

A south Orlando caterer at 6925 Lake Ellenor Dr whose retrieved review text was thin: the one featured review we retrieved praises its bar and event staff, by name, for making a wedding reception memorable. The places record carries no rating; it ranks on a Google-review aggregate of 4.8★ across 145 reviews, the second-deepest base in this list.

8. Pearson’s Catering — Net Score 93.4 (College Park)

Blended 4.90★ from 45 reviews — Google 4.9★ (45).

A College Park caterer at 627 Brookhaven Dr whose retrieved client review text was too thin to distill responsibly; it ranks on a Google-review aggregate of 4.9★ across 45 reviews.

9. GrillMaster Catering & Restaurant — Net Score 93.3 (Ocoee)

Blended 4.80★ from 108 reviews — Google 4.8★ (108).

An Ocoee caterer-and-restaurant at 2222 Ocoee Apopka Rd whose retrieved review text was too thin to distill responsibly; catering is a named primary service on its own listing, and it ranks on a Google-review aggregate of 4.8★ across 108 reviews.

10. Millenia Cafe & Catering — Net Score 93.1 (Millenia)

Blended 4.86★ from 36 reviews — Google 4.86★ (36).

Get: Food and event-day execution that exceeded expectations, in the one detailed review we retrieved — its writer praises the on-site captain by name.

Skip: Planning-stage communication, on that same detailed account: missed check-ins, slow replies and a forgotten cake-cutting detail. One review is not a consensus, but it is the most specific evidence this category produced, and it cuts both ways.

Local detail: A cafe-and-catering operation at 4303 Vineland Rd in the Millenia district, ranked on a places-verified 4.86★ across 36 Google reviews.

Part of Orlando Citizen’s Top Businesses in Orlando series. Net Scores are recalculated from fresh public review data each edition.

For businesses

Own a restaurant or venue?

You can ask Orlando Citizen to review it. Asking never buys a verdict and never guarantees coverage — but every request is read by an editor. Request a review.

Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank

Sofia Marchetti

Food & Dining reporter for Orlando Citizen. Covers restaurant openings, closings and DBPR inspection results, tied to the Top Businesses rankings.