Where to Eat in Kissimmee Right Now
The No. 1 barbecue in our Orlando rankings, a Vine Street Mexican institution, a Loop pizzeria with a 91.9 Net Score, and a Cuban supper club — Kissimmee's best tables, mapped.
3 minute read
Kissimmee feeds two cities at once: the visitors pouring off US-192, and the Osceola County locals who never eat on the corridor if they can help it. The trick to eating well here is knowing which Kissimmee a restaurant belongs to. The locals’ Kissimmee eats downtown, on Broadway and Monument Avenue. The corridor’s Kissimmee eats big — dinner shows, resort dining rooms, and one genuinely excellent Cuban night out at Sunset Walk. Here is where we would send you, pulled from our rankings and our own research. Everything below also appears on the Kissimmee hub and the Top Spots Map.
The headliner: Big John’s Rockin’ BBQ
Start where our rankings start. Big John’s Rockin’ BBQ, at 220 E. Monument Avenue in downtown Kissimmee, is No. 1 in our Best BBQ in Orlando rankings with a Net Score of 90.9 — the top barbecue score in the region. The room leans into its name, all rock memorabilia and easy noise, and the kitchen does the slow work properly: brisket, ribs, pulled pork and pulled chicken, with sides made in-house daily. It serves breakfast, lunch and dinner, which makes it the easiest good decision in downtown — smoked meat after a morning on the lakefront, a few blocks away. Read the full story in our winner feature on Big John’s, then go hungry.
The Mexican institution: El Tapatio
On West Vine Street — US-192’s older, local name — El Tapatio Mexican Restaurant at 1804 W. Vine St. holds the No. 4 spot in our Best Mexican Restaurants in Orlando rankings, Net Score 85.4. This is a big-menu, family-run Jalisco-style kitchen: birria tacos, a molcajete loaded with grilled chicken, shrimp, steak and chorizo under melted cheese, fajitas, mariscos, and combination plates built for people who cannot decide. We give it the full treatment in our El Tapatio profile. If your group orders one thing to pass around, make it the molcajete.
Pizza, two ways
Kissimmee’s ranked pizza pick sits up at The Loop: Pienezza Pizza, at 3236 N. John Young Parkway, No. 7 in our Best Pizza in Orlando rankings with a Net Score of 91.9. It is a family-run New York-style shop — thin and crispy pies, a deep-dish Sicilian, a Grandma pie, garlic knots and stromboli — and it earns its score on crust discipline. Downtown, Broadway Pizza Bar at 403 Broadway plays the other role: the neighborhood pie-and-a-pint place, with specialty pizzas, a patio and live-music energy on the main street. Our Kissimmee pizza guide puts the two head to head.
The downtown table: Savion’s Place
For a sit-down dinner that feels like an occasion without leaving downtown, Savion’s Place at 16 E. Dakin Avenue is the reservation to make. Family owned and operated, it serves fresh New American cooking at lunch and dinner, handles groups and celebrations gracefully, and has the patio every downtown wishes it had. It is unranked in our Top Businesses tables — which says more about category coverage than quality — and it is the first name out of local mouths when you ask where downtown actually eats.
The night out: Sunset Walk and ette
On Kissimmee’s west side, the Promenade at Sunset Walk is the corridor’s best evening. Its anchor restaurant, Estefan Kitchen Orlando at 3269 Margaritaville Blvd., is Emilio and Gloria Estefan’s Cuban restaurant, nightclub and live-music room — vaca frita, lechón, paella and ropa vieja, with a band most nights and dancing after. A few minutes away, the ette hotel’s Salt & The Cellar brings a chef-driven Mediterranean dining room to 3001 Sherberth Road, inside the boutique hotel that ranks No. 5 in our Best Hotels in Orlando rankings (Net Score 91.7). We pair the two in our Sunset Walk date-night guide. And when the plan is simply dinner and a show, Medieval Times on West Vine Street still does its four-course, eat-with-your-hands tournament nightly — corny, committed, and better than it has any right to be.
The through-line: Kissimmee’s best eating is specific. A downtown smokehouse, a Vine Street Mexican institution, a Loop pizzeria, a Cuban supper club. Skip the corridor’s interchangeable grills and eat the places with names attached.
Photo: Pokemonprime, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Related Stories
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank
