Winter Park Paid Parking Pilot: Test It at Dinky Dock, Publish the Counts, Then Decide
Lake Baldwin came out of Winter Park's parking pilot when the city read its own 2002 agreement. Test the one lot with real pressure — and publish the counts.
5 minute read
OPINION — From the Porch
There are two parks in this story, and they are not the same park. That is the whole column, really. Everything else is just showing the work.
Lake Baldwin Park is 23.16 acres at 2000 South Lakemont Avenue, with roughly 100 to 150 parking spaces, marked and unmarked, and the city’s only dog-friendly park. Dinky Dock is 1.56 acres on Lake Virginia, near Rollins College — a boat ramp with limited parking, where trailer spaces are first-come, first-served and, once they fill, boaters go looking for a space offsite. On a Saturday, those are two different problems wearing the same name: parking.
On September 9, the Winter Park City Commission voted 5–0 to advance a paid-parking pilot covering both of them. Staff proposed charging nonresidents $2 to $3 an hour, or $20 for the day, with enforcement from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m., residents parking free after registering up to two vehicles per property, and payment taken cashlessly, by app or code or text. Six days later, on September 15, the city took Lake Baldwin back out. Not because the politics got hot — because a settlement agreement from November 2002 says Winter Park and Orlando residents must have equal access, on the same terms, to the parks each city owns around that lake. Orlando residents would have needed the same exemption as Winter Park residents, and the city decided that was a larger undertaking than one lot was worth. The city manager’s announcement also credited the input of citizens.
Both things are true: the commission voted for the pilot, and then the city read its own paperwork and narrowed it. I would like us to notice that the second thing is what good government looks like from a porch. A fact arrived, and the plan got smaller and more honest.
What happened next, and what has not
On November 11, the commission approved Ordinance 3385-26, the Paid Parking Pilot Program, on first reading. Our Government desk’s report of that meeting is careful, and I want to be just as careful: a first reading is not adoption, the ordinance returns for a second reading, and the city’s recap of the meeting publishes no vote counts and none of the pilot’s streets, hours or rates. So nobody — not me, not either of my colleagues on this page today — can tell you the final price of parking at Dinky Dock, because the city has not published it in that document. What we have is a September proposal and a November first reading, with daylight between them.
Clarence Howard is right that the person who uses a scarce space at its busiest hour is a reasonable person to ask to pay, and that a pilot with an end date is a better instrument than a permanent program passed in a hurry. G. L. Dyer is right that $20 a day is a real amount of money for a family driving in from the next city over, and that a public lake should not quietly become a residents-only amenity with a payment app at the gate. I have read both of their columns, as I hope you will, and I am not going to pretend one of them is simply wrong. The street test is narrower than either argument.
The street test for one small lot
At Dinky Dock, the pressure is documented in the city’s own description: limited spaces, trailers, weekends. At Lake Baldwin, the neighbours who use the dog park said — before the agreement even surfaced — that visitors are not routinely forced out of that lot, even on busy weekends. One site had a counting problem. The other had a counting absence. A pilot that treats them as one problem would have learned nothing from either.
So here is the porch version, in the order it should happen. Before the second reading, publish the pilot’s actual terms — streets, hours, rates — in one place a resident can read on a phone. Before the first ticket, publish the baseline counts the September design promised to collect: how full is that lot, hour by hour, on the Saturdays that are supposed to justify this? Run the test at the one site where the evidence points, for the stated season — a spring 2027 launch for a six-month pilot has been reported, with no firm date — and publish the counts again at the end, next to the money: what came in, what the vendor and enforcement took out, and what Park Avenue, where parking is still free for three hours on the street, should or should not learn from it. Officials have already said results would be evaluated before any expansion is considered, and that nothing else has been committed to. Hold them to exactly that — no more, and no less.
Print the counts for one small lot, before and after, and let the street — not the slide deck — decide what happens next.
Read the other sides: Clarence Howard argues the user should pay, with the ledger published, and G. L. Dyer argues the fee is a paywall on a public lake. The Citizen’s news report is the Government desk’s account of the November 11 meeting, and all three columns live on the Opinion hub.
Sources & notes
City of Winter Park, Regular Meeting Recap, November 11, 2026 — Ordinance 3385-26 (Paid Parking Pilot Program) approved on first reading; the recap publishes no vote counts and no pilot streets, hours or rates — checked via the Citizen’s Government desk report, Winter Park City Commission: Paid Parking Pilot and Red-Light Cameras Pass First Reading Nov. 11. Winter Park City Commission, September 9, 2026 meeting record and staff presentation — the 5–0 vote to advance a two-park pilot and the proposed terms ($2–$3 per hour for nonresidents, $20 flat day rate, 8 a.m.–8 p.m. enforcement, $0.25–$0.35 vendor transaction fee paid by the parker, residents free after registering up to two vehicles per property) — proposals, not terms published in the November recap. City Manager Randy Knight’s September 15, 2026 release removing Lake Baldwin Park from the pilot, citing the November 2002 Baldwin Park Settlement Agreement and citizen input, as reported by Bungalower and the Winter Park Voice. Winter Park Chamber of Commerce visitor brochure (free on-street parking up to 3 hours; free 4-hour municipal lots) and the City’s Merchant Employee Parking Program page. Winter Park Voice, September 15, 2026 (parking fine raised from $25 to $30). Read the other two columns in today’s crossover: the Opinion hub carries all three.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank
