Opinion

Winter Park Paid Parking Pilot: Charge the User, Publish the Ledger, Keep the Sunset

Winter Park's paid parking pilot passed a first reading on Nov. 11. Charge the visitor who uses Dinky Dock — but publish the terms and the full ledger first.

5 minute read

ShareFacebookX

OPINION — The Howard Ledger

One ordinance number. That is where this column starts, because it is where honest argument has to start: 3385-26.

On November 11, the Winter Park City Commission approved Ordinance 3385-26, establishing a Paid Parking Pilot Program, on first reading. First reading. Not final adoption, not a meter running, not a ticket written. The ordinance has to come back for a second reading before it can take effect, and the city’s own meeting recap — the document our Government desk reported from this morning — publishes no vote counts and none of the pilot’s streets, hours or rates.

I support the idea behind it. I do not support voting the second reading blind. Both of those sentences belong in the same column, because both of them are conservative.

Two questions, as always

Every spending proposal gets two questions from me: who pays, and what did we promise them?

Who pays, under the design the commission advanced in September, is the person who uses the scarce thing. Staff proposed charging nonresidents $2 to $3 an hour, or a flat $20 a day, to park at Dinky Dock — a small boat-ramp park on Lake Virginia where trailer parking is first-come, first-served and the lot fills on weekends. Winter Park residents, who already pay for that park through their city taxes, would park free after registering up to two vehicles per property.

That is the right order of payment. A visitor who launches a boat on a Saturday is using a city asset at its most crowded hour. Asking that visitor to pay for the use is not a tax grab. It is the opposite of one. The alternative — spreading the cost across every Winter Park household whether they own a boat or not — is the genuinely unfair ledger, and it is the one we reach for whenever we are too polite to charge the user.

What did we promise them? A pilot. The word matters. A pilot is a test with an end, judged on numbers, not a program that quietly becomes permanent because nobody scheduled the vote to kill it. September’s design even carried the right furniture: a two-to-three-week warning period before tickets, real-time occupancy tracking, and a six-month horizon that has been reported with a spring 2027 target and no firm start date. Keep all of that. Write the sunset into the ordinance so it cannot be forgotten.

The other side’s best point, honestly stated

G. L. Dyer is right about one thing, and I will not pretend otherwise. Twenty dollars a day is not a trivial sum, and a fee schedule that reads fine in a commission chamber can land very differently on a family that drives in from Orlando for an afternoon on the lake. He is wrong about whose bill this is — a public park is not free to run because admission is free — but he is right that the day rate is the number in this proposal that needs defending out loud, in public, before the second reading. If the city cannot defend $20, it should lower it and say why.

Margaret Shepherd is right about a second thing. Lake Baldwin Park was removed from this pilot on September 15, six days after the commission voted 5–0 to include it, because a 2002 settlement agreement requires Winter Park and Orlando residents to have equal access to the parks around that lake. That is not an embarrassment. That is a government reading its own promises before it cashes a cheque. I want the same discipline applied to the rest of the pilot.

What the second reading owes us

Publish the terms before the vote: the streets, the hours, the rates, exactly as they will appear in the ordinance — not as they appeared in a September slide deck. Publish the full ledger, too: what the vendor keeps — September’s proposal had the parker paying a transaction fee of 25 to 35 cents on top — what enforcement costs, and what the city honestly expects to net from one small lot, now that the larger site, with its 100 to 150 spaces, is out of the plan. An early estimate of $100,000 or more assumed both parks. Nobody should quote it for one.

And fence the pilot the way we fence any dedicated charge. No expansion — not to Park Avenue, where parking is free today for up to three hours on the street and four in the municipal lots — without a separate, explicit vote that says so. City staff have said results would be evaluated before any expansion is considered, and that no expansion has been committed to. Put that in writing, in the ordinance, where a future commission has to reckon with it.

Charge the user, publish the ledger, keep the sunset — and this pilot earns its second reading.

Read the other sides: G. L. Dyer argues the fee is a paywall on a public lake, and Margaret Shepherd asks what the counts at Dinky Dock actually prove. The Citizen’s news report is the Government desk’s account of the November 11 meeting, and all three columns live on the Opinion hub.

Sources & notes

City of Winter Park, Regular Meeting Recap, November 11, 2026 — Ordinance 3385-26 (Paid Parking Pilot Program) approved on first reading; the recap publishes no vote counts and no pilot streets, hours or rates — checked via the Citizen’s Government desk report, Winter Park City Commission: Paid Parking Pilot and Red-Light Cameras Pass First Reading Nov. 11. Winter Park City Commission, September 9, 2026 meeting record and staff presentation — the 5–0 vote to advance a two-park pilot and the proposed terms ($2–$3 per hour for nonresidents, $20 flat day rate, 8 a.m.–8 p.m. enforcement, $0.25–$0.35 vendor transaction fee paid by the parker, residents free after registering up to two vehicles per property) — proposals, not terms published in the November recap. City Manager Randy Knight’s September 15, 2026 release removing Lake Baldwin Park from the pilot, citing the November 2002 Baldwin Park Settlement Agreement and citizen input, as reported by Bungalower and the Winter Park Voice. Winter Park Chamber of Commerce visitor brochure (free on-street parking up to 3 hours; free 4-hour municipal lots) and the City’s Merchant Employee Parking Program page. Winter Park Voice, September 15, 2026 (parking fine raised from $25 to $30). Read the other two columns in today’s crossover: the Opinion hub carries all three.

Filed under · · · ·

Editor’s Picks

  1. 1NewsEpic Universe Faces Its First Holiday Season
  2. 2ReviewsThe 10 Best Coffee Shops in Orlando
  3. 3TourismMagic Kingdom
  4. 4Top BusinessesHaan Coffee: Mills 50’s Korean-Inflected Roaster Tops Orlando Coffee
  5. 5ReviewsThe 10 Best Attractions & Things To Do in Orlando

Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank

Clarence Howard

Writes The Howard Ledger, the Orlando Citizen's conservative column. Trusts ledgers over press releases: a tax fenced for one purpose should stay fenced, growth should pay its own way, and every spending proposal gets two questions — who pays, and what did we promise them?