The 10 Best Seafood Restaurants in Orlando
Orlando's 10 best seafood restaurants, ranked by real review data — Eddie V's leads a field of 29 on Restaurant Row.
4 minute read
Orlando is a hundred miles from either coast and eats seafood like a port city — Restaurant Row fields two of the top four names on this list, Disney Springs’ Boathouse carries the deepest review base in the category, and the rest of the top 10 runs from a Winter Park coastal kitchen to wholesale market counters where the fish case is the menu. We scored 39 seafood listings across the metro; 29 cleared our 25-review evidence bar.
How we rank: every business is ordered by its Net Score (0–100), which blends its public ratings from Google, TripAdvisor, Yelp and the other review sources we could retrieve — weighted by review volume, then adjusted so a handful of five-star reviews can’t outrank a proven track record (Bayesian shrinkage, m = 200, disclosed in our methodology). A business needs at least 25 public reviews to be ranked. Scores compare only within this category. Ratings retrieved November 16, 2026.
1. Eddie V’s Prime Seafood — Net Score 97.0 (Dr. Phillips / Restaurant Row)

Blended 4.88★ from 10,491 reviews — Google 4.75★ (1,060), OpenTable 4.9★ (9,431).
Get: The Chilean sea bass and the lobster tacos are the orders reviewers single out, with the bananas Foster butter cake closing the meal; live music and polished service run through the praise.
Skip: The lounge at full tilt — reviewers note occasional slow service and real noise when the room is busy.
Local detail: The Dr. Phillips flagship of Restaurant Row, at 7488 W Sand Lake Rd — the corridor’s special-occasion seafood room, and the deepest OpenTable following in this category.
2. The Current Seafood Counter — Net Score 92.8 (College Park)
Blended 4.80★ from 234 reviews — Google 4.8★ (234).
A College Park seafood counter on Edgewater Drive whose retrieved review text was too thin to distill responsibly; its Google-review aggregate (4.8★ across 234 reviews, via Restaurantji — the places record carries no rating) is the strongest small-sample score in the category, and the shrinkage adjustment still leaves it second.
3. The Boathouse — Net Score 92.5 (Lake Buena Vista (Disney Springs))
Blended 4.70★ from 21,675 reviews — Google 4.7★ (3,091), OpenTable 4.7★ (18,584).
Get: The raw bar and oyster selection lead the praise, with the lobster bisque and lobster roll behind it, all of it on the Disney Springs waterfront.
Skip: Premium prices, high noise, and waits even with a reservation — the dockside setting is the draw and the tax.
Local detail: The biggest review base in Orlando seafood: more than 21,000 ratings across the sources we retrieved, at 1620 E Buena Vista Dr.
4. Ocean Prime — Net Score 92.4 (Dr. Phillips / Restaurant Row)
Blended 4.73★ from 573 reviews — Google 4.73★ (573).
A steak-and-seafood house on Restaurant Row (7339 W Sand Lake Rd) whose retrieved review text was too thin to distill responsibly; it ranks on a places-verified 4.73★ across 573 Google reviews — a smaller, steadier book than the rooms above it.
5. Boston’s Fish House — Net Score 91.8 (Winter Park)
Blended 4.69★ from 676 reviews — Google 4.69★ (676).
A Winter Park fish house on Aloma Avenue whose retrieved review text was too thin to distill responsibly; its places-verified 4.69★ across 676 Google reviews is one of the strongest mid-volume scores in the category.
6. Bar Harbor Seafood — Net Score 91.4 (South Orlando)
Blended 4.68★ from 379 reviews — Google 4.68★ (379).
Get: The format itself: a working wholesale seafood market — the places listing still trades as Wholesale Seafood To The Public — with a lunch counter attached, so the fish case is the menu’s source.
Local detail: At 2000 Premier Row in south Orlando; market-first seafood retail is a format no other name in this top 10 runs.
7. Lighthouse Seafood Market & Cafe — Net Score 91.4 (Lake Mary)
Blended 4.77★ from 92 reviews — Google 4.77★ (92).
A Lake Mary market-and-cafe on Country Club Road whose retrieved review text was too thin to distill responsibly; a places-verified 4.77★ across 92 reviews is the highest raw Google rating in the published ten, held to seventh by the volume adjustment.
8. King Cajun Crawfish — Net Score 90.9 (Mills 50)
Blended 4.65★ from 531 reviews — Google 4.65★ (531).
A Mills 50 crawfish house at 924 N Mills Ave whose retrieved review text was too thin to distill responsibly; it ranks on a places-verified 4.65★ across 531 Google reviews — the strongest score on the Mills Avenue corridor in this category.
9. The Osprey — Net Score 90.5 (Baldwin Park)
Blended 4.63★ from 235 reviews — Google 4.63★ (235).
A Baldwin Park seafood room on New Broad Street whose retrieved review text was too thin to distill responsibly; the places record lists it as seafood restaurant, cocktail bar and American restaurant in one, and its 4.63★ across 235 Google reviews clears the bar cleanly.
10. Reel Fish Coastal Kitchen & Bar — Net Score 90.3 (Winter Park)
Blended 4.61★ from 3,490 reviews — Google 4.76★ (228), OpenTable 4.6★ (3,262).
Get: Shrimp and creamy cheese grits and the Firecracker Shrimp lead the OpenTable diner praise, with the Low Country Boil behind them and carrot cake and Key lime pie to finish.
Skip: Noise, and occasional waits when the Winter Park room fills.
Local detail: At 1234 N Orange Ave in Winter Park — and the incumbent magazine’s own Best Restaurant winner, which makes its tenth-place Net Score the honest surprise of this list: a deep, happy review base (3,490 ratings) at a slightly cooler temperature than the rooms above it.
Part of Orlando Citizen’s Top Businesses in Orlando series. Net Scores are recalculated from fresh public review data each edition.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
The Winner & More Rankings
- Read the Winner FeatureMeet the winner: Eddie V's Prime Seafood
- On the MapFind the No. 1 spot on the Top Spots map
- The NeighborhoodDr. Phillips — the area guide
- More RankingsOrlando’s best Korean Restaurants, ranked
- More RankingsOrlando’s best Caterers, ranked
- More RankingsThe best Sandwich Shops & Delis in Orlando — the full list
- The Full IndexAll 30 Top Businesses in Orlando rankings
- Browse by AreaOrlando by neighborhood — every area guide
For businesses
Own a restaurant or venue?
You can ask Orlando Citizen to review it. Asking never buys a verdict and never guarantees coverage — but every request is read by an editor. Request a review.
About the byline
Sofia Marchetti
Food & Dining reporter for Orlando Citizen. Covers restaurant openings, closings and DBPR inspection results, tied to the Top Businesses rankings.
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank


