Three Christmas Carols in Orlando 2026: Thornton Park, Orlando Shakes and Winter Park, Compared
A 1977 living room in Thornton Park, the full classic at Orlando Shakes, and a youth musical in Winter Park: Orlando's three Christmas Carols, compared.
4 minute read
The facts first: Orlando has three productions of A Christmas Carol this season, and they could hardly be more different. PaperMap Theater & Co. in Thornton Park runs November 13–December 13 — a family in 1977, snowed in with a broken television, staging Dickens from blankets and boxes. Orlando Shakes in Ivanhoe Village runs November 25–December 24 — Jim Helsinger’s full musical adaptation in the Margeson Theater, 1 hour 50 minutes including intermission, rated PG, no children under 5. CFCArts Youth Theatre in Winter Park plays three performances only, December 18–19 — a musical staged by performers in grades 3–12, the company’s third time mounting the show. One story, three scales: a living room, a mainstage, and a school-age cast. This guide exists so you can pick on purpose.
The comparison files from our Ivanhoe Village hub, home of the largest of the three. Bungalower’s November 13 roundup first gathered the three productions in one place; what follows adds the practical layer — who each version is for, and what to check before you book.
PaperMap Theater, Thornton Park: the small, strange one
PaperMap Theater & Co., 2 N. Summerlin Avenue in Thornton Park, takes Dickens back to 1977: a snowstorm, a broken television, and a family staging A Christmas Carol with whatever the house provides — blankets, boxes, and each other. Expect nostalgia, music and family chaos, per the company’s billing as reported by Bungalower. It opened first, on November 13, and closes first, on December 13 — the shortest remaining window of the three, and the only one already running today. This is the version for the theatre-goer who has seen the classic staging before and wants the story told sideways. Tickets are through the company’s own site, papermaptheater.com.
Orlando Shakes, Ivanhoe Village: the classic, at full scale
Orlando Shakes, 812 E. Rollins Street in the Lowndes Shakespeare Center at Loch Haven, stages Helsinger’s adaptation in the Margeson Theater from November 25 to December 24, with music, theatrical effects and the three ghosts played straight. The practical facts from the company’s own materials: performances at 2:00 and 7:30 p.m.; running time 1 hour 50 minutes with a 15-minute intermission; rated PG, with heavy theatrical fog and smoke; children under 5 are not admitted. Two dates carry extras — a Pick Your Price preview on opening night, November 25, and a holiday pajama party on December 23, both per Bungalower’s roundup — and the December 17 evening performance is ASL-interpreted and audio-described, per the production’s published access information. This is the version for a family with children five and up who want the tradition itself, done properly, within sight of the Holocaust Center’s Ivanhoe Village neighbourhood and the museum row around Loch Haven. Tickets are through orlandoshakes.org; this guide publishes no price, because the company’s own pages are the only honest source for one and prices vary by date.
CFCArts Youth Theatre, Winter Park: the one-weekend musical
Central Florida Community Arts’ youth production plays Trinity Preparatory School, 5700 Trinity Prep Lane in Winter Park, for three performances: December 18 at 7:00 p.m. and December 19 at 2:00 and 7:00 p.m. The cast is the point — performers in grades 3–12, in a show the organisation stages every three years as a holiday tradition, this year for the third time. It is the version for families whose own children are the age of the cast, and for anyone who believes a Christmas Carol sung by actual children lands differently. Three performances means it sells on a different clock from the other two: decide in November, not December. Tickets are through cfcarts.com.
Which Scrooge, for whom
Want it now, and want it different? PaperMap — it is already open and it closes December 13. Want the full traditional production, with access performances and a Christmas Eve closing date? Orlando Shakes, November 25–December 24 — pair it with the season’s other big openings in our Dazzling Nights guide and the Festival of Trees guide, both a short drive from Loch Haven. Want to watch the story carried by young performers, and can commit to one specific weekend? CFCArts, December 18–19. Or take Bungalower’s closing advice, which this desk endorses: three productions, three different takes — pick your Scrooge, or support local arts and pick all three.
Sources & notes
All three productions, venues and date ranges; the PaperMap 1977 premise; the Shakes Pick Your Price preview (November 25) and pajama party (December 23); the CFCArts cast (grades 3–12), Trinity Preparatory School venue, December 18–19 performance times and third-staging note: Bungalower, “Bah, Humbug! Three Versions of ‘A Christmas Carol’ Are Haunting Orlando Stages This Holiday Season,” November 13, 2026, checked November 16, 2026. Orlando Shakes run (November 25–December 24, 2026), Helsinger adaptation, Margeson Theater and Lowndes Shakespeare Center address: Orlando Shakes’ own season announcement and 2026–27 season materials, checked November 16, 2026. Running time (1 hour 50 minutes including a 15-minute intermission), PG rating, fog/smoke note, under-5 admission rule and the December 17 ASL-interpreted and audio-described performance: the production’s published listings (GoWayFind and CultureOwl holiday guides drawing on the company’s pages), checked November 16, 2026. No ticket prices are published here: none of the three companies’ own pages checked for this guide states a single price, and resale listings are not a box office.
Photo: Orlando Citizen file photo from our Dazzling Nights coverage; see that story for the full credit.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank

