The 10 Best Auto Repair Shops in Orlando
Orlando's best auto repair shops by real review data — six shops clear the evidence bar, led by Orlando Import Auto Specialists at 93.0.
5 minute read
Finding a mechanic you trust is the hardest recommendation in Orlando to earn, so this list is built only on numbers we could actually retrieve. We scored 36 auto repair shops across the metro on the public figures retrievable at compile time — and only 6 carry a retrievable rating-and-review-count pair at ranking volume. Many established shops’ figures could not be retrieved from the sources we use, so this is a short list by evidence, not by effort, and it will grow as our coverage does. Orlando Import Auto Specialists leads it, on the strength of the highest retrievable ratings in the field.
How we rank: every business is ordered by its Net Score (0–100), which blends its public ratings from Google, TripAdvisor, Yelp and the other review sources we could retrieve — weighted by review volume, then adjusted so a handful of five-star reviews can’t outrank a proven track record (Bayesian shrinkage, m = 200, disclosed in our methodology). A business needs at least 25 public reviews to be ranked. Scores compare only within this category. Ratings retrieved November 15, 2026.
1. Orlando Import Auto Specialists — Net Score 93.0 (Colonialtown)

🏆 Winner feature: Read our full profile of Orlando Import Auto Specialists — why it won, what to try, and the badge to share.
Blended 4.85★ from 307 reviews — Google 4.95★ (98), Apple Maps 4.8★ (209).
Get: Honest communication and diagnostics that finish the job: reviewers describe friendly, professional staff and excellent repair quality, including an MDX whose surge-and-hesitation fault a dealership had chased for over two years and which this shop traced to a throttle-body cleaning. Reviewers also praise the system that shows the work to be done with prices so you approve only what you want, and the follow-up summary after service.
Local detail: On East South Street in Colonialtown, open Monday to Friday on the record. Longtime customers say they have brought their cars here for years — and that an oil-change visit does not turn into the long list of extra fixes they associate with dealerships.
2. Sloan’s Automotive — Net Score 91.3 (Conway)
Blended 4.92★ from 95 reviews — Google 4.92★ (95).
Get: The full diagnostic, sorted honestly: reviewers say the shop tells you what is super necessary, what you could do yourself to save a few bucks, and what can wait — with everything explained clearly, no upsell on work that is not needed, reasonable prices and a quick turnaround. One reviewer singles out the complete diagnostic report the shop sent and then talked through on the phone, question by question.
Local detail: A family-owned shop on East Michigan Street in Conway. Reviewers describe driving out of their way to keep coming back, and families who use it for every car they own.
3. Maitland Importers Inc — Net Score 90.1 (Downtown Orlando)
Blended 4.85★ from 67 reviews — Google 4.97★ (36), Yelp 4.7★ (31).
Get: Volvo and Mini Cooper work, and only that: Yelp reviewers praise fair, reasonable pricing — the repeated highlight is that the price was great considering the work done, and that this is a MINI — plus quick turnaround and staff who explain everything in detail. Service manager Ian is named again and again as patient and helpful, and more than one reviewer calls it the most honest mechanic they have had.
Local detail: Despite the name, this shop is in Orlando, not Maitland — on West Church Street downtown. A family-owned Volvo service business there since 1994, with customers who say they have brought their Volvos (and a daughter’s Mini) here for over a decade.
4. Wilcox & Son Automotive Repair — Net Score 89.9 (SoDo)
Blended 4.97★ from 39 reviews — Google 4.97★ (39).
Get: Honest and fair recommendations, in reviewers’ own words: one Google reviewer quoted by the shop says Brandee took the time to explain exactly what the car needed and did not try to upsell unnecessary services, at fair pricing; a parent reviewer values the peace of mind that a daughter’s car in Orlando is kept in good running order, and a Yelp reviewer cites the flat rates on offer.
Local detail: Family owned and operated since 2010 on West Illiana Street in SoDo, run around an ASE Master technician per the shop’s own record. Reviewers mention a clean waiting area with free fresh coffee — and at least one loyal customer drives in from Minneola rather than go elsewhere.
5. Riker’s Automotive & Tire — Net Score 83.3 (South Orlando)
Blended 4.20★ from 286 reviews — Yelp 4.2★ (286).
Get: Fair treatment without the invented upsell: Yelp reviewers say the shop has always treated them fairly, never pushed repairs that did not need fixing, with reasonable pricing and cars ready within a few hours. Quick, short-notice work-ins get repeated praise — one highlight, repeated across eight reviews, credits Elwin with making a service both extremely quick and a learning experience — and stranded visitors whose cars died on Disney trips are a recurring rescue story.
Skip: Waits can run longer than planned: reviewers with good outcomes still note the wait stretched, and one found the service could be slightly more organized.
Local detail: On Central Florida Parkway in South Orlando, open from 7 a.m. including Saturdays on the record — the shop in this ranking best set up for an early drop-off or a visitor emergency near the attractions corridor.
6. Expert Car Care — Net Score 80.6 (Winter Park)
Blended 3.50★ from 82 reviews — Yelp 3.5★ (82).
Review text was too thin to distill responsibly: the retrievable sources for this shop yielded ratings data but not enough review text to support Get/Skip/Local detail without inventing it. It is ranked on its retrieved Yelp figures alone.
Only 6 businesses in the Orlando metro currently clear our 25-review evidence bar in this category; we publish what the data supports rather than pad the list. Many established shops’ figures could not be retrieved from the sources we use for this edition, and the list will grow as coverage does. Part of Orlando Citizen’s Top Businesses in Orlando series. Net Scores are recalculated from fresh public review data each edition.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
The Winner & More Rankings
- Read the Winner FeatureOrlando Import Auto Specialists — inside Orlando’s best auto repair
- On the MapSee Orlando Import Auto Specialists on the Top Spots map
- The NeighborhoodColonialtown — the area guide
- More RankingsBest Golf Cart Dealers in Orlando, ranked by score
- More RankingsThe best RV Dealers in Orlando — the full list
- More RankingsThe best Craft Breweries in Orlando — the full list
- The Full IndexAll 30 Top Businesses in Orlando rankings
- Browse by AreaOrlando by neighborhood — every area guide
For businesses
Own a restaurant or venue?
You can ask Orlando Citizen to review it. Asking never buys a verdict and never guarantees coverage — but every request is read by an editor. Request a review.
About the byline
Sofia Marchetti
Food & Dining reporter for Orlando Citizen. Covers restaurant openings, closings and DBPR inspection results, tied to the Top Businesses rankings.
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank


