ReviewsTop Businesses

The 10 Best Fish and Chips in Orlando

Orlando's 10 best fish and chips, from a College Park Irish pub to Clermont chippies, ranked by real review data. The Castle leads at 92.4.

6 minute read

ShareFacebookX

Fish and chips in Orlando is mostly a pub dish — Irish and British rooms from College Park to the Highway 27 corridor frying cod and haddock to order — with a dedicated Clermont chippy, a Haines City pie shop and one Southern catfish house crashing the list. We scored 29 spots across the metro and 28 clear our evidence bar; two familiar names, Finnegan’s and An Tobar, sit this edition out while temporarily closed. The Castle Irish Pub and Restaurant leads with a Net Score of 92.4.

How we rank: every business is ordered by its Net Score (0–100), which blends its public ratings from Google, TripAdvisor, Yelp and the other review sources we could retrieve — weighted by review volume, then adjusted so a handful of five-star reviews can’t outrank a proven track record (Bayesian shrinkage, m = 200, disclosed in our methodology). A business needs at least 25 public reviews to be ranked. Scores compare only within this category. Ratings retrieved November 15, 2026.

1. The Castle Irish Pub and Restaurant — Net Score 92.4 (College Park)

Orlando Citizen Best Fish and Chips 2026 award badge
Orlando Citizen Award — Best Fish and Chips 2026Awarded to The Castle Irish Pub and Restaurant, No. 1 in this ranking.

🏆 Winner feature: Read our full profile of The Castle Irish Pub and Restaurant — why it won, what to try, and the badge to share.

Blended 4.80★ from 620 reviews — Google 4.8★ (613), TripAdvisor 4.7★ (7).

Get: The fish and chips — the pub’s best-selling dish, served with mushy peas in a generous portion reviewers praise for not feeling overly greasy, with the fish fresh and fried perfectly; the shepherd’s pie, which one reviewer called the best they have ever had, and the Reuben fritters are the other repeat orders.

Skip: A Friday-evening crowd: reviewers describe the room packed and noisy — like a good pub should be, but not the night for a quiet dinner — and the Brussels appetizer drew mixed reviews.

Local detail: A College Park Irish pub on Edgewater Drive with live music, trivia evenings and a patio poured with Kilkenny Nitro Cream Ale; it was named Critic’s Choice for Best Irish in the 2026 Orlando Sentinel Foodie Awards.

2. Best of British Pub & Cafe — Net Score 91.8 (Clermont)

Blended 4.74★ from 814 reviews — Google 4.8★ (584), TripAdvisor 4.8★ (77), Yelp 4.5★ (153).

Get: The fish and chips — with curry sauce, per one delighted review — and the Full English breakfast, with proper English back bacon, black pudding, Heinz beans and toast made with English bread; the Sunday roast is the weekly event reviewers plan around, and one seven-person table’s run through fish & chips, doner kebab, cottage pie, Scotch egg and coronation chicken came back all-delicious.

Skip: Consistency is the caveat — TripAdvisor’s own review summary notes occasional inconsistencies in portion size and quality, and one takeout order arrived with raw fish and soggy chips.

Local detail: Owner Martin works the room and makes customers feel like family; there is a double-decker bus with a backstory the staff will tell you, a British goods shop alongside the pub, and live football on eight TVs just off Highway 27.

3. The Friar Tuck — Net Score 90.6 (Clermont / Four Corners)

Blended 4.75★ from 398 reviews — Google 4.99★ (154), TripAdvisor 4.6★ (244).

Get: The Legendary Fish and Chips — cod with proper hand-cut English-style chips, repeatedly called some of the best reviewers have had in years — and the Full English breakfast, which one visiting café couple rated superb against their own professional standard; Cornish pasties, steak pie and spotted dick round out the homemade board.

Skip: A minority of reviewers report off nights amid the praise, including service friction and one flatly disappointed return visit — and there is no kids menu, so small children share from a parent’s plate.

Local detail: Proudly Nottingham — Robin Hood country — in its roots, with an attached English/Irish market selling meat pies and real UK Cadbury eggs, a stage for live music, and a Sunday roast served from noon until it’s gone.

4. Clermont Fish House — Net Score 90.1 (Clermont)

Blended 4.69★ from 544 reviews — Google 4.96★ (225), TripAdvisor 4.5★ (319).

Get: The cod & chips in a light, crispy batter — reviewers call it phenomenally filling, cooked perfectly and never greasy, with thick, chunky chips and homemade-tasting tartar sauce — the haddock & chips is the other big filet, and the sticky toffee pudding with custard is the finish reviewers insist on.

Skip: Portions split opinion at the margins: amid the raves, one TripAdvisor reviewer called their single small piece of cod and roughly 20 chips a pitiful quantity for the price.

Local detail: A family-run British fish house on Highway 50 dressed with UK sports memorabilia and a red telephone booth — and it keeps chip-shop hours, closed Mondays and Tuesdays.

5. The Proper Pie Company — Net Score 89.0 (Haines City)

Blended 4.71★ from 253 reviews — Google 4.87★ (141), TripAdvisor 4.5★ (112).

Get: The cod and chips — a big, flaky piece of fish in a perfectly crunchy golden batter that reviewers say stays crisp even after a splash of malt vinegar, with haddock on special days — and the handmade double-crust pies, Steak & Ale above all, that give the shop its name.

Skip: Plan around the calendar: the kitchen is open Wednesday to Saturday only, and it is a small takeaway-first room in a Haines City strip mall rather than a sit-down destination.

Local detail: A British bakery and takeaway that also sells its mini pies at local markets and stocks British groceries and chocolates to take home — reviewers who grew up in England say it reminds them of home.

6. Claddagh Cottage Irish Pub — Net Score 88.5 (Hourglass District)

Blended 4.59★ from 669 reviews — Google 4.63★ (378), TripAdvisor 4.7★ (49), Yelp 4.5★ (242).

Get: The flaky Steak & Ale Pie and the savory Cottage Pie earn the highest marks in the retrieved reviews, with sausage rolls and Scotch eggs behind them — and the Guinness pour patrons single out by name. The fish & chips is the pub-grub headline this ranking scores it on, but the review text we could retrieve talks loudest about the pies.

Local detail: A cozy Hourglass District trad pub on Curry Ford Road with a stone fireplace, steel-tipped darts and live Irish music — an evenings-only room, opening at 4 p.m.

7. Lucky Leprechaun Irish Pub — Net Score 87.7 (International Drive)

Blended 4.54★ from 711 reviews — Google 4.6★ (579), TripAdvisor 4.3★ (132).

Get: The fish & chips and a pint of Guinness while the GAA plays on multiple screens; the Full Irish Breakfast — black pudding and all — is the other signature order in the retrieved listings.

Local detail: Bills itself as the oldest and only Irish pub on I-Drive, between trolley stops 8 and 9 — and it is the budget pick on this list, with cheap prices reviewers and the record both note.

8. Harp & Celt Irish Pub & Restaurant — Net Score 87.6 (Downtown Orlando)

Blended 4.53★ from 849 reviews — Google 4.58★ (631), TripAdvisor 4.4★ (218).

Get: The fish & chips and Shepherd’s Pie, the signature pair the retrieved summary names, with a well-poured Guinness alongside; curry fries, boxty and whiskey wings fill out the pub board.

Local detail: A family-owned downtown pub on South Magnolia Avenue built for Premier League mornings — traditional Irish recipes made in-house, per the house, with outdoor seating for match days.

9. Bubba Gump Shrimp Co. — Net Score 87.4 (Universal CityWalk)

Blended 4.50★ from 4,608 reviews — Google 4.5★ (4,608).

Get: Forrest’s Seafood Feast and the Bang Bang Shrimp lead the retrieved praise at this shrimp-first house — its fish & chips is the featured plate that puts it on area fish & chips roundups, but reviewers here talk shrimp, gumbo and jambalaya loudest, with a slice of Key Lime Pie to finish.

Local detail: The movie-themed CityWalk seafood room at Universal — family-friendly, with outdoor seating and reservations, and theme-park crowds to match.

10. The Catfish Place — Net Score 87.4 (St. Cloud)

Blended 4.51★ from 1,564 reviews — Google 4.63★ (753), TripAdvisor 4.4★ (811).

Get: The fried catfish — fresh Lake Okeechobee catfish, per the house summary — with hush puppies and cheese grits; frog legs, gator tail and fried green tomatoes round out the Southern board reviewers drive to St. Cloud for.

Local detail: St. Cloud’s original catfish restaurant, established in 1973 by its own billing, with a full bar and daily happy hour — a Southern fish house, not a British chippy, and proud of the difference.

Part of Orlando Citizen’s Top Businesses in Orlando series. Net Scores are recalculated from fresh public review data each edition.

For businesses

Own a restaurant or venue?

You can ask Orlando Citizen to review it. Asking never buys a verdict and never guarantees coverage — but every request is read by an editor. Request a review.

Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank

Sofia Marchetti

Food & Dining reporter for Orlando Citizen. Covers restaurant openings, closings and DBPR inspection results, tied to the Top Businesses rankings.