The 10 Best Fish and Chips in Orlando
Orlando's 10 best fish and chips, from a College Park Irish pub to Clermont chippies, ranked by real review data. The Castle leads at 92.4.
6 minute read
Fish and chips in Orlando is mostly a pub dish — Irish and British rooms from College Park to the Highway 27 corridor frying cod and haddock to order — with a dedicated Clermont chippy, a Haines City pie shop and one Southern catfish house crashing the list. We scored 29 spots across the metro and 28 clear our evidence bar; two familiar names, Finnegan’s and An Tobar, sit this edition out while temporarily closed. The Castle Irish Pub and Restaurant leads with a Net Score of 92.4.
How we rank: every business is ordered by its Net Score (0–100), which blends its public ratings from Google, TripAdvisor, Yelp and the other review sources we could retrieve — weighted by review volume, then adjusted so a handful of five-star reviews can’t outrank a proven track record (Bayesian shrinkage, m = 200, disclosed in our methodology). A business needs at least 25 public reviews to be ranked. Scores compare only within this category. Ratings retrieved November 15, 2026.
1. The Castle Irish Pub and Restaurant — Net Score 92.4 (College Park)

🏆 Winner feature: Read our full profile of The Castle Irish Pub and Restaurant — why it won, what to try, and the badge to share.
Blended 4.80★ from 620 reviews — Google 4.8★ (613), TripAdvisor 4.7★ (7).
Get: The fish and chips — the pub’s best-selling dish, served with mushy peas in a generous portion reviewers praise for not feeling overly greasy, with the fish fresh and fried perfectly; the shepherd’s pie, which one reviewer called the best they have ever had, and the Reuben fritters are the other repeat orders.
Skip: A Friday-evening crowd: reviewers describe the room packed and noisy — like a good pub should be, but not the night for a quiet dinner — and the Brussels appetizer drew mixed reviews.
Local detail: A College Park Irish pub on Edgewater Drive with live music, trivia evenings and a patio poured with Kilkenny Nitro Cream Ale; it was named Critic’s Choice for Best Irish in the 2026 Orlando Sentinel Foodie Awards.
2. Best of British Pub & Cafe — Net Score 91.8 (Clermont)
Blended 4.74★ from 814 reviews — Google 4.8★ (584), TripAdvisor 4.8★ (77), Yelp 4.5★ (153).
Get: The fish and chips — with curry sauce, per one delighted review — and the Full English breakfast, with proper English back bacon, black pudding, Heinz beans and toast made with English bread; the Sunday roast is the weekly event reviewers plan around, and one seven-person table’s run through fish & chips, doner kebab, cottage pie, Scotch egg and coronation chicken came back all-delicious.
Skip: Consistency is the caveat — TripAdvisor’s own review summary notes occasional inconsistencies in portion size and quality, and one takeout order arrived with raw fish and soggy chips.
Local detail: Owner Martin works the room and makes customers feel like family; there is a double-decker bus with a backstory the staff will tell you, a British goods shop alongside the pub, and live football on eight TVs just off Highway 27.
3. The Friar Tuck — Net Score 90.6 (Clermont / Four Corners)
Blended 4.75★ from 398 reviews — Google 4.99★ (154), TripAdvisor 4.6★ (244).
Get: The Legendary Fish and Chips — cod with proper hand-cut English-style chips, repeatedly called some of the best reviewers have had in years — and the Full English breakfast, which one visiting café couple rated superb against their own professional standard; Cornish pasties, steak pie and spotted dick round out the homemade board.
Skip: A minority of reviewers report off nights amid the praise, including service friction and one flatly disappointed return visit — and there is no kids menu, so small children share from a parent’s plate.
Local detail: Proudly Nottingham — Robin Hood country — in its roots, with an attached English/Irish market selling meat pies and real UK Cadbury eggs, a stage for live music, and a Sunday roast served from noon until it’s gone.
4. Clermont Fish House — Net Score 90.1 (Clermont)
Blended 4.69★ from 544 reviews — Google 4.96★ (225), TripAdvisor 4.5★ (319).
Get: The cod & chips in a light, crispy batter — reviewers call it phenomenally filling, cooked perfectly and never greasy, with thick, chunky chips and homemade-tasting tartar sauce — the haddock & chips is the other big filet, and the sticky toffee pudding with custard is the finish reviewers insist on.
Skip: Portions split opinion at the margins: amid the raves, one TripAdvisor reviewer called their single small piece of cod and roughly 20 chips a pitiful quantity for the price.
Local detail: A family-run British fish house on Highway 50 dressed with UK sports memorabilia and a red telephone booth — and it keeps chip-shop hours, closed Mondays and Tuesdays.
5. The Proper Pie Company — Net Score 89.0 (Haines City)
Blended 4.71★ from 253 reviews — Google 4.87★ (141), TripAdvisor 4.5★ (112).
Get: The cod and chips — a big, flaky piece of fish in a perfectly crunchy golden batter that reviewers say stays crisp even after a splash of malt vinegar, with haddock on special days — and the handmade double-crust pies, Steak & Ale above all, that give the shop its name.
Skip: Plan around the calendar: the kitchen is open Wednesday to Saturday only, and it is a small takeaway-first room in a Haines City strip mall rather than a sit-down destination.
Local detail: A British bakery and takeaway that also sells its mini pies at local markets and stocks British groceries and chocolates to take home — reviewers who grew up in England say it reminds them of home.
6. Claddagh Cottage Irish Pub — Net Score 88.5 (Hourglass District)
Blended 4.59★ from 669 reviews — Google 4.63★ (378), TripAdvisor 4.7★ (49), Yelp 4.5★ (242).
Get: The flaky Steak & Ale Pie and the savory Cottage Pie earn the highest marks in the retrieved reviews, with sausage rolls and Scotch eggs behind them — and the Guinness pour patrons single out by name. The fish & chips is the pub-grub headline this ranking scores it on, but the review text we could retrieve talks loudest about the pies.
Local detail: A cozy Hourglass District trad pub on Curry Ford Road with a stone fireplace, steel-tipped darts and live Irish music — an evenings-only room, opening at 4 p.m.
7. Lucky Leprechaun Irish Pub — Net Score 87.7 (International Drive)
Blended 4.54★ from 711 reviews — Google 4.6★ (579), TripAdvisor 4.3★ (132).
Get: The fish & chips and a pint of Guinness while the GAA plays on multiple screens; the Full Irish Breakfast — black pudding and all — is the other signature order in the retrieved listings.
Local detail: Bills itself as the oldest and only Irish pub on I-Drive, between trolley stops 8 and 9 — and it is the budget pick on this list, with cheap prices reviewers and the record both note.
8. Harp & Celt Irish Pub & Restaurant — Net Score 87.6 (Downtown Orlando)
Blended 4.53★ from 849 reviews — Google 4.58★ (631), TripAdvisor 4.4★ (218).
Get: The fish & chips and Shepherd’s Pie, the signature pair the retrieved summary names, with a well-poured Guinness alongside; curry fries, boxty and whiskey wings fill out the pub board.
Local detail: A family-owned downtown pub on South Magnolia Avenue built for Premier League mornings — traditional Irish recipes made in-house, per the house, with outdoor seating for match days.
9. Bubba Gump Shrimp Co. — Net Score 87.4 (Universal CityWalk)
Blended 4.50★ from 4,608 reviews — Google 4.5★ (4,608).
Get: Forrest’s Seafood Feast and the Bang Bang Shrimp lead the retrieved praise at this shrimp-first house — its fish & chips is the featured plate that puts it on area fish & chips roundups, but reviewers here talk shrimp, gumbo and jambalaya loudest, with a slice of Key Lime Pie to finish.
Local detail: The movie-themed CityWalk seafood room at Universal — family-friendly, with outdoor seating and reservations, and theme-park crowds to match.
10. The Catfish Place — Net Score 87.4 (St. Cloud)
Blended 4.51★ from 1,564 reviews — Google 4.63★ (753), TripAdvisor 4.4★ (811).
Get: The fried catfish — fresh Lake Okeechobee catfish, per the house summary — with hush puppies and cheese grits; frog legs, gator tail and fried green tomatoes round out the Southern board reviewers drive to St. Cloud for.
Local detail: St. Cloud’s original catfish restaurant, established in 1973 by its own billing, with a full bar and daily happy hour — a Southern fish house, not a British chippy, and proud of the difference.
Part of Orlando Citizen’s Top Businesses in Orlando series. Net Scores are recalculated from fresh public review data each edition.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
The Winner & More Rankings
- Read the Winner FeatureThe Castle Irish Pub and Restaurant — inside Orlando’s best fish and chips
- On the MapFind the No. 1 spot on the Top Spots map
- The NeighborhoodCollege Park — the area guide
- More RankingsBest Seafood Restaurants in Orlando, ranked by score
- More RankingsBest Korean Restaurants in Orlando, ranked by score
- More RankingsBest Caterers in Orlando, ranked by score
- The Full IndexAll 30 Top Businesses in Orlando rankings
- Browse by AreaOrlando by neighborhood — every area guide
For businesses
Own a restaurant or venue?
You can ask Orlando Citizen to review it. Asking never buys a verdict and never guarantees coverage — but every request is read by an editor. Request a review.
About the byline
Sofia Marchetti
Food & Dining reporter for Orlando Citizen. Covers restaurant openings, closings and DBPR inspection results, tied to the Top Businesses rankings.
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank


