Bella Italia: Conway’s Family-Owned Brick-Oven Table
Garlic knots, New York and Sicilian pies, and a dining room full of regulars — Bella Italia on East Michigan Street is the Italian room Conway adopted as its own.
3 minute read
Every Orlando neighborhood of a certain age has one Italian room that functions as its dining room — the place for team dinners, grandparent birthdays and Friday nights when nobody wants to cook. In Conway, that room is Bella Italia Pizza, family-owned at 4662 E. Michigan Street, serving brick-oven pizza and a full Italian menu to a neighborhood that has adopted it completely.
The room and the formula
Bella Italia describes itself as a small restaurant with a big soul, and the description is accurate advertising. This is a family operation in the old sense: the menu runs from brick-oven pizzas through pastas, strombolis, calzones and wings, the dining room is built for families rather than dates, and the hospitality is the warm, unhurried kind that turns first-time visitors into a standing Friday order. In a corridor of takeout counters and diners, Bella Italia is the place Conway sits down.
What to order
Start with the garlic knots — the house signature, served with the spaghetti and famous in the neighborhood in their own right. The pizza program splits two ways: New York–style pies with the foldable crust the name promises, and a Sicilian pizza the kitchen describes as crispy yet fluffy, layered with tangy tomato sauce and mozzarella. Both travel well, which matters, because half of Conway seems to carry a Bella Italia box home on any given evening.
Past the pizza, the menu does the Italian-American canon properly: spaghetti with a rich meat sauce, lasagna, eggplant parmesan, plus the strombolis and calzones that make the place a one-call answer for feeding a table of mixed appetites. Buffalo wings handle the contingent that wandered into an Italian restaurant wanting bar food, and tiramisu closes. It is not a menu trying to surprise you. It is a menu trying to feed you, repeatedly, for years — a harder trick.
Takeout, catering and the standing order
Half of Bella Italia’s life happens outside its dining room. The restaurant runs a full takeout trade — call ahead and the box is timed to the drive — and publishes a separate catering menu, which is how a family pizzeria becomes the default caterer of Conway’s graduation parties, office lunches and post-game feeds. The kitchen also runs specials, the kind of rotating deals that give regulars a reason to vary the standing order.
That standing order is a real phenomenon on Michigan Street. Conway is a neighborhood of repeat customers — the same families, the same tables, the same pies — and Bella Italia’s family ownership shows in how the room handles them: this is a restaurant that knows its regulars’ orders the way a diner knows its counter crowd. Newcomers get the same welcome, which is precisely how a newcomer becomes a regular. In a city where restaurants open with venture money and close with a locked door eighteen months later, a family-owned room compounding goodwill year after year is its own kind of achievement.
Where it fits
Bella Italia is unranked in this magazine — the rankings have reached Conway only lightly so far — and this profile makes no claim otherwise. What it has earned is the neighborhood: a family-owned room, on the neighborhood’s own street, at neighborhood prices, holding down the sit-down end of a corridor we map in full in Where to Eat in Conway. Its Michigan Street neighbors include the dumplings at Penda Chinese and the loaded potatoes at Super Potatoes; Bella Italia is the one you book for grandma.
The practical move: go for lunch or dinner any day of the week, order knots for the table whether or not anyone asks, and take the Sicilian if the table can agree on one pie. Conway families have run this exact play for years. There is a reason.
More from the neighborhood on the Conway hub, and the wider region’s ranked dining on the Top Spots Map.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Related Stories
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank
