Where to Eat in Conway: Conway Road and Michigan Street
A diner, a family Mexican room, a market-counter taqueria, brick-oven pizza and a Puerto Rican potato — Conway's two corridors hold a complete neighborhood table.
3 minute read
Conway does not have a dining district. It has two workhorse corridors — Conway Road (State Road 15) running north–south, and East Michigan Street crossing it — and a set of local rooms that feed the neighborhood in every register it actually needs: diner breakfast, family Mexican, market-counter tacos, Chinese takeout, brick-oven pizza and one magnificent Puerto Rican potato. None of these places is ranked in this magazine yet, and none needs to be; this is the honest table of Conway, researched on the ground.
Conway Road: the north–south table
Bob’s Family Restaurant (5120 Conway Road) is the corridor’s breakfast anchor — an old-school diner in a strip plaza, doing plate-sized pancakes, biscuits and gravy, country fried steak and an open-faced roast beef sandwich for a room full of regulars. It is a breakfast-and-lunch institution of the kind Orlando keeps losing; Conway is keeping this one.
A few doors south, El Potro Mexican Restaurant (5180 S. Conway Road) handles the family-dinner shift: tacos de carne asada and al pastor, a Burrito Grande built to share, sizzling fajitas, enchiladas verdes and a full bar. It is the Conway Road room you take a crowd to when nobody can agree — the menu is long enough to end arguments.
North on the road, La Espiga — Tienda Mexicana & Restaurant (4024 Conway Road) is the connoisseur’s pick: a Mexican grocery and butcher counter with a restaurant inside, turning out birria tacos, sopes, tamales and fresh tortillas. Shop the market shelves after you eat; everyone does. And for takeout night, Sunflower Chinese Kitchen (5152 Conway Road) covers the neighborhood’s General Tso’s, lo mein and house fried rice requirements a few doors from Bob’s.
Michigan Street: the east–west table
Cross to East Michigan Street, in the blocks around Conway Road, and the corridor changes accent. Bella Italia Pizza (4662 E. Michigan Street) is the family-owned Italian room — brick-oven and New York–style pies, garlic knots, spaghetti with meat sauce — profiled in full in our Bella Italia piece. Next door in spirit, Super Potatoes (4722 E. Michigan Street) does one thing with total commitment: Boricua-style loaded baked potatoes, headlined by the Tripleta and a cheeseburger-stuffed version, with quesitos and coconut flan for dessert. And Penda Chinese Restaurant (4638 E. Michigan Street) gives the street its dumpling option — Shanghai steamed dumplings and pork buns alongside the Chinese-American standards.
The Michigan Street cluster has one more essential stop, though nobody eats there except the dog: Woof Gang Bakery & Grooming Conway, the neighborhood’s ranked pet bakery at 4574 E. Michigan. Dinner for the family, treats for the dog, one trip.
Two corridors, one junction
The geography is the convenience: Conway Road and Michigan Street meet in the middle of the neighborhood, so the entire table above sits within a short drive — much of it within a few blocks — of that junction. A Conway family can do a diner breakfast, a market-and-tacos lunch and a pizza night without leaving the neighborhood or fighting a single tourist corridor. That self-sufficiency is old Conway in edible form: this community fed itself from its own main street for a century before Orlando’s dining scene existed, and its restaurants still run on repeat local trade rather than destination traffic. Expect regulars, expect the staff to know them, and expect to become one faster than you planned.
How to choose
Breakfast or a diner lunch: Bob’s. A crowd and margaritas: El Potro. The best tacos on the corridor and a grocery run in one stop: La Espiga. Family pizza night: Bella Italia. A loaded-potato event: Super Potatoes. Takeout on the couch: Sunflower or Penda. Conway will not win Orlando’s fine-dining argument, and it is not entering it — what it has is a complete neighborhood table, priced for weeknights, within a few blocks of itself.
More Conway coverage is on the Conway hub, and the region’s ranked restaurants are plotted on the Top Spots Map.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Related Stories
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank