Sister Honey’s: The Championship Case on Michigan Street
A national pie champion runs SoDo's neighborhood bakery. Hummingbird cake, key lime pie and a rotating case that rewards regulars — Sister Honey's, reviewed.
3 minute read
Every neighborhood has one counter where the regulars do not look at the case before ordering — they ask what is good today, because they already trust the answer. In SoDo, that counter is Sister Honey’s, the small bakery at 247 E. Michigan St. that has been turning out scratch-made cakes, pies and cupcakes since 2012 and now ranks No. 4 in our Best Bakeries in Orlando rankings with a Net Score of 91.5.
The bakery describes itself plainly — an award-winning Orlando bakery specializing in gourmet cakes and pies — but the awards are not marketing garnish. Owner Evette Rahman built the shop on championship pie-making: coverage of the bakery credits her with multiple national blue ribbons and Best in Show honors at the National Pie Championships, and the shop’s reputation in Orlando’s dessert scene rests on exactly that competition-honed precision applied to a neighborhood case.
The case, and why it changes
The first thing to understand about Sister Honey’s is that the display case is not a fixed menu. It rotates — by season, by holiday, by what the kitchen is excited about — and regulars treat that rotation as a feature. The constants are the Southern canon, executed with unusual care. Hummingbird cake, the spiced banana-pineapple-pecan layer cake with cream cheese icing, is the slice most often named as the shop’s signature. Coconut cake runs tall and custard-filled. German chocolate, pistachio and carrot cakes hold down the classic end, and the cupcake case has produced its own devotees — the red velvet cupcakes in particular attract the kind of superlatives reviewers usually save for anniversary dinners.
Then there is the pie case, which is where the championships show. Key lime — made the Florida way, tart first — anchors it, joined in rotation by strawberry cream, peanut butter and lemon icebox pies. Lemon, in its meringue form, gets its own following: a filling that stays sharp and smooth under a disciplined, tall meringue, in a crust with structure. This is baking that reads as technique rather than novelty, and it is why a small Michigan Street shop draws customers from well beyond the neighborhood.
How locals use the shop
Sister Honey’s operates Tuesday through Saturday, opening late morning — a schedule that shapes how SoDo uses it. Weekday slices are the neighborhood’s afternoon ritual. Saturdays are for whole cakes and pies, and they move fast; sellouts are a normal part of the shop’s rhythm rather than an exception. Whole pies and celebration cakes are order-ahead business — the bakery takes custom and holiday orders through its website, and major holidays run on an online-order system with slots that fill. The practical translation: if a Sister Honey’s pie is the plan for a holiday table, it should be ordered when the ordering window opens, not the week of.
The shop also anchors the sweet end of Michigan Street’s food corridor. It sits minutes from the ranked pizza-and-taco plaza at 419 E. Michigan St. and on the same street as the À La Cart food-truck lawn at the east end — which makes a Michigan Street dinner followed by a Sister Honey’s box the district’s easiest dessert strategy, provided you buy the box before dinner, while the case is still full. We map the whole corridor in Where to Eat in SoDo and pair the bakery with the neighborhood’s other morning anchor in our SoDo brunch and sweet mornings guide.
The verdict
Orlando has bigger bakeries and trendier dessert bars. It has very few shops where a single baker’s competition record is this visible in every slice. Sister Honey’s is SoDo’s proof that a neighborhood bakery, done at a national-championship standard, becomes a destination without ever acting like one. Go on a weekday afternoon, ask what is freshest, and take a second slice to go. You will understand both halves of that instruction by the second bite. Find it on the Orlando Top Spots Map, under the SoDo hub.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Related Stories
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank