Where to Eat in Parramore Right Now
No. 2 barbecue at Jesse's, soul food at Nikki's, plates on the avenue at Sister Soul Food and a cone at the revived Sweetie's window: the short, true map of where Parramore eats.
3 minute read
Ask where to eat in Parramore and the honest answer is: at the tables that held this neighborhood together when almost nobody outside it was paying attention. This is not a long list, and it does not need to be. It is a short list of rooms with decades in them, plus one revived ice cream window — the working map of a neighborhood that feeds itself first and visitors gladly, in that order.
The anchor: Jesse’s Rib Shack
Start at 2202 West Pine Street. Jesse’s Rib Shack, founded by Jesse James Jackson in 1987 and still family-run under his grandson, ranks No. 2 for barbecue in Orlando in our rankings with a Net Score of 87.3. The order is ribs or rib tips, barbecue chicken, and the house Magic Sauce taken as the house intends it, with mac and cheese alongside. If you eat one meal in Parramore, eat this one — then argue about it with the regulars, who have been having that argument, happily, since the eighties.
The soul-food room: Nikki’s Place
At 742 Carter Street, Nikki’s Place Southern Cuisine is the neighborhood’s soul-food institution: a restaurant whose roots run to Roser’s, opened on this street in 1949, renamed in 1999, lost to fire in 2015 and reopened in 2017 because the Aiken family refused to let it close. Fried catfish, smothered pork chops, collard greens, candied yams, black-eyed peas — the canon, cooked patiently — plus a real breakfast service with shrimp and grits, and sweet potato pie or peach cobbler to finish. It is unranked in our citywide lists and foundational in this neighborhood, and both facts belong in the same sentence.
On Parramore Avenue itself: Sister Soul Food
At 436 South Parramore Avenue, Sister Soul Food serves the avenue directly: generous Southern plates built around fried chicken, mac and cheese, smothered pork chops and smothered turkey wings, with banana pudding as the correct ending. It is a family-owned, takeout-friendly room of the kind every strong food neighborhood runs on — the place you call when the day needs feeding rather than impressing. It carries no ranking from us and needs none; its constituency is the street it sits on.
The sweet finish: Sweetie’s Ice Cream
Dessert is at 212 South Orange Blossom Trail, where Sweetie’s Ice Cream — No. 7 for ice cream in our rankings, Net Score 91.1 — has revived the old Goff’s walk-up window, open since 1948, burned in 2022 and reopened in November 2023 by Eric McIntosh and Jelani Gray. Soft serve, banana splits and the signature mini pancakes with a swirl of ice cream: the correct Parramore dessert, at the correct Parramore price, eaten standing up the way Orlando has eaten it for three-quarters of a century.
A note on what is not on this list
Parramore’s food map has gaps that are themselves part of the record: a neighborhood that once supported a full commercial ecosystem along Church and South streets — in the era when the Wells’Built Hotel and the South Street Casino anchored a Black business district of doctors, shops and entertainment — now runs a shorter bench, the long result of disinvestment and highway-era losses. We list the rooms we have researched and can stand behind today, and we would rather publish a short, true list than pad it. When a new Parramore kitchen earns its place, this page’s successors will say so.
How to run the Parramore table
Do it as a progression, not a pit stop: a late-morning hour at the Wells’Built Museum, lunch at Jesse’s or Nikki’s, a cone at Sweetie’s on the way out. Pin all of it on our Orlando Top Spots Map. And a word of plain dealing: these are neighborhood restaurants with neighborhood hours and neighborhood crowds, especially at lunch and on game days at the stadiums nearby. Check a kitchen’s own channels before a special trip, expect a wait when the room is full, and understand that you are eating where Orlando’s history actually happened — which is worth considerably more than a shorter line somewhere forgettable.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Related Stories
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank