Maitland, Explained: Twenty-One Lakes, One Landmark and a Fort’s Borrowed Name
Incorporated in 1885 around a fort named for a captain who never visited, Maitland grew into a small city holding a National Historic Landmark, an Oscar-qualifying film festival and a raptor hospital. A local's guide.
3 minute read
Visitors know Orlando by its corridors — the theme parks, International Drive, downtown’s towers. Maitland, ten minutes north of downtown, is the counter-argument: one of Central Florida’s oldest incorporated suburbs, a small city of twenty-one lakes threaded through just over five square miles, where the cultural landmarks are a 1930s artist colony and a nonprofit cinema, and the tallest thing in town is a cypress.
From a fort that never saw its namesake
The city’s name is an irony it has carried since 1838. During the Second Seminole War, the U.S. Army built Fort Maitland on the western shore of the big lake as a rest stop between Fort Mellon and Fort Gatlin — naming it for Captain William Seton Maitland, a hero of the wars who, by the city’s own historical account, never set foot here, having died in a battle near Tampa. The Seminole name for the place, Fumecheliga, translates roughly as “Musk Melon Place.” Settlement followed the fort’s abandonment — drawn by spring water and pine forests — and grew with citrus after the Civil War. The railroad arrived in 1880, connecting Lake Maitland to Sanford and Jacksonville’s markets. On July 17, 1885, the community incorporated as the Town of Lake Maitland, the third town in Orange County to do so, with carpenter William H. Waterhouse — whose 1884 house still stands on Lake Lily — among the founders who helped win its charter. The great freeze of 1894–95 emptied many groves and households, but the town endured; in 1959 a new charter shortened the name to Maitland. The largest of its lakes still carries the captain’s name: Lake Maitland, 451 acres.
A cultural density that embarrasses bigger cities
Consider what this small city holds. The Maitland Art Center — André Smith’s 1937 Research Studio, funded by Mary Curtis Bok — is greater Orlando’s only National Historic Landmark, designated in 2014. The Enzian Theater has championed independent film since 1985 and produces the Florida Film Festival, an Oscar-qualifying event. The Audubon Center for Birds of Prey, on Lake Sybelia, rehabilitates 600 to 800 raptors a year — and sits minutes from where the Florida Audubon Society held its first meeting in 1900. Three institutions of national standing, one small city, no admission turnstiles between them.
How a Maitland day runs
Morning starts at KOS Coffee on South Orlando Avenue — No. 2 in our coffee rankings at a 92.5 Net Score (category winner feature: Haan Coffee) — or with a class at The Yoga Shala, Krista Shirley’s Ashtanga studio at 140 Circle Drive, ranked No. 5 in Best Yoga & Pilates in Orlando at 97.3 (winner feature: Elevate Yoga), which reopened in Maitland in May 2024. Midday belongs to Lake Lily and the Waterhouse Residence Museum; Sundays bring the farmers’ market to Independence Lane by City Hall. Shoppers detour to LaBella Intimates & Boutique at 481 South Orlando Avenue, No. 9 in Best Boutiques in Orlando at 95.3 (winner feature: Be On Park).
Evenings and occasions
Dinner runs through our eating guide — Antonio’s two floors, Luke’s oak fire, Francesco’s Sicilian oven, Boku’s sushi, Parea’s Greek table — and occasions run through the Venue on Lake Lily, the Maitland Civic Center at 641 Maitland Avenue South: founded in 1965 as a nonprofit funded by residents rather than the city, still independently run, and ranked No. 6 in Best Wedding Venues in Orlando at 91.2 (winner feature: Four Seasons weddings). Its signature Corks and Forks tasting night turns the venue into a showcase for the same restaurants this guide just listed — the city’s food scene literally catering its own civic center’s fundraiser. Fall brings the Rotary Art Festival around Lake Lily; spring brings the film festival crowd to the Enzian.
Maitland rewards the unhurried. Plot it on the Orlando Top Spots Map, park once, and walk — a city founded by a carpenter, funded by patrons, and built at walking pace still works best at exactly that pace.
Photo: Ebyabe, CC BY, via Wikimedia Commons.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Related Stories
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank