Bella Tuscany: The Summerport Dining Room That Gave Horizon West a Real Dinner
A family-owned Italian restaurant with house-made pasta and a 700-label wine list on Lake Speer's village parkway — the anchor dinner house of Horizon West's first village center.
3 minute read
Every young suburb needs one restaurant that proves it can do dinner properly — a room with a real wine list, a kitchen with a point of view, and regulars who would be annoyed if you described their neighborhood as a food desert. In Horizon West, that restaurant is Bella Tuscany, the family-owned Italian dining room at 13424 Summerport Village Parkway in Summerport Village Center, on the shore side of Lake Speer. It is unranked in our magazine rankings, which have not scored Horizon West yet; it is profiled here on researched merit, as the anchor of the village dining we survey in Where to Eat in Horizon West.
A neighborhood Italian, built like a destination
Bella Tuscany describes itself as a family-owned local neighborhood Italian restaurant, and the telling detail is how much ambition hides inside that modest claim. The restaurant features a wine list it counts at more than 700 labels, recognized by Wine Spectator, a full bar, chef-prepared daily features, and patio dining alongside the main dining room. That combination — neighborhood warmth, destination cellar — is rare in master-planned suburbia, where Italian usually means a pizza counter with a red-checkered sideline. Here the pizza exists, but it shares the menu with the full Tuscan canon: antipasti, house-made pastas, seafood, and veal and chicken classics, plus a private dining room for the celebrations a family suburb generates constantly.
The setting does half the persuading before the menu arrives. Summerport Village Center was the first village center in Horizon West, built around Lake Speer with a village green and lakefront pavilion, and Bella Tuscany sits on its parkway like the anchor tenant of a small town’s main street — because, in the plan’s terms, that is exactly what it is. We tell the center’s story in Summerport Village Center; Bella Tuscany is the reason most non-residents discover it.
What to order
Start where the kitchen shows its hand: the antipasti and the pastas. Caprese and beef carpaccio open the traditional way, the mussels arrive in a sauce regulars mop up without embarrassment, and the house-made pasta section is the menu’s center of gravity — lasagna built the slow way, seafood pastas, and the seasonal risottos that regulars track, including the lobster and pumpkin risotto that has become a local talking point when it appears. From the grill and sauté sections, the pork chop and grilled salmon are the steady orders, and the chicken Parmesan does the comfort-food work a neighborhood room must do well or hear about.
Dessert is not an afterthought. The tiramisu draws the kind of superlatives from regulars that a critic should report rather than repeat, and the chocolate mousse cake closes the richer end of the menu. With a list that deep, let the staff drive the wine: a 700-label cellar in a suburb is a resource, and the by-the-glass program and staff picks are how a Tuesday dinner borrows the cellar without buying it.
Who it serves, and when
Bella Tuscany’s double life is its strength. At lunch and early evening it is the village’s family room — carryout and delivery run alongside the dining room, and the patio absorbs the stroller-and-grandparents multigenerational table that Horizon West produces in bulk. Later, with the bar lit and the patio settling over the village, it becomes the default celebration and date-night room for the whole western side of the plan, a role we assign it again in Horizon West Evenings Out. Live music appears on certain days, per the restaurant, which suits the room: this is a place designed to be lingered in.
Practical notes, stated as patterns rather than promises: the restaurant serves lunch and dinner daily, reservations are wise on weekends, and menus and features change, so check the restaurant’s own site before a special-occasion drive. Find it from the Horizon West hub or our Orlando Top Spots Map. In a community still arguing about what it will become, Bella Tuscany is the settled answer on one question at least: where dinner is.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Related Stories
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank