From Nashville Retreat to Palmer’s Kingdom: The History of Bay Hill
Bay Hill began as a Tennessee businessmen's golf retreat in 1961. Then Arnold Palmer played it once, leased it, bought it — and a neighborhood grew in his orbit.
3 minute read
Most famous neighborhoods begin as a town. Bay Hill began as a retreat — a private golf escape built on lake country southwest of Orlando — and then one man fell for it so completely that he bought it, moved his winter life into it and spent four decades polishing it. The community that exists today, an established enclave of homes between the fairways and the Butler Chain of Lakes, is the sediment of that single long relationship between Arnold Palmer and a Dick Wilson golf course.
1961: a Nashville retreat on the lakes
The original Bay Hill was a businessmen’s project: a group from Nashville, Tennessee, hired architect Dick Wilson — one of the defining Florida course designers of his era — and builder Bob Simmons to create a winter golf retreat on 270 acres along the Butler Chain. The first 18 holes, the Champion and Challenger nines, opened in 1961, seeded with Tifway Bermudagrass — the PGA Tour notes Bay Hill was the first course in the world to use that now-standard surface. After Wilson’s death in 1965, Simmons added the Charger nine, bringing the property to the 27 holes it has today. The surrounding land was still the old southwest Orlando of groves and lake roads; Walt Disney’s land purchases nearby were announced the same year Palmer first saw the place.
1965–1975: Palmer plays it, leases it, buys it
In 1965 the club invited Palmer, Jack Nicklaus, Don Cherry and Dave Ragan to play an exhibition to promote the course. Palmer won the day — accounts of the round agree he played it brilliantly — and, by the story he told for the rest of his life, told his wife Winnie that he had just played the best course in Florida and wanted to own it. He took a five-year lease with an option to buy in 1970 and took full ownership in 1975. Bay Hill became his winter home and business headquarters, and he set about revising the course in his own image over the following decades, including a comprehensive reworking of the greens and bunkering, and a 2009 rebuilding of every green.
The residential community grew in the club’s orbit through the 1970s and 1980s — the era that still defines its housing stock, from ranch-style homes to lakefront estates, on the larger lots of that period’s planning. Corners of it keep older stories still: the Bay Point section, on Lake Tibet, spent a decade or more as a Boy Scout camp before its development, and in 1974 Disney used the property as a staging area while filming The Treasures of Matecumbe on the Butler Chain’s channels. Bay Hill was becoming a suburb; it never stopped being lake country first.
1979: the tournament arrives, and stays
Palmer had won the Florida Citrus Open in 1971, when it was played at Rio Pinar east of Orlando. In 1979 the tournament moved west to his own course as the Bay Hill Citrus Classic, won in a playoff by Bob Byman, and it has been played at Bay Hill every March since. The event took Palmer’s name in 2007, becoming the Arnold Palmer Invitational; after his death in September 2016, the winner’s presentation added the red cardigan sweater in his memory, first awarded in 2017. The tournament’s modern status — a PGA Tour Signature Event with an elite limited field — is the current chapter of a story that began with a retreat for Tennessee businessmen. Our tournament week guide covers the modern edition.
What the history explains
Bay Hill’s character — quiet, established, golf-first, resistant to spectacle — is not an accident of zoning. It is what happens when a neighborhood’s center holds one ownership, one standard and one family for half a century: the club remains in the Palmer family today, run by his daughter Amy and her husband Roy Saunders. The course Palmer bought is the No. 1 course in the magazine’s Orlando golf rankings; read its winner feature for the full assessment, find the club on the Orlando Top Spots Map, and see our account of Palmer’s wider Orlando legacy for what he built beyond the fairways.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Related Stories
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank