News

Merrywood Estate Winter Park: Commission Votes 4-1 to Save Most of the Rogers House

Months after a February demolition permit put James Gamble Rogers II's largest and most ornate home at risk, Winter Park commissioners voted 4–1 on November 11 to allow a rare lakefront lot split in exchange for a covenant preserving about 6,200 square feet of the 1939 estate, though the binding text still awaits approval.

4 minute read

ShareFacebookX

After the vote in Winter Park’s commission chamber on Wednesday, November 11, the property owner Steve Lockwood and Betsy Owens, the executive director of Friends of Casa Feliz, briefly embraced — an improbable scene, reported by the Winter Park Voice and Bungalower, at the close of a standoff that for most of this year seemed likeliest to end with a bulldozer. A prospective buyer had obtained a demolition permit in February for Merrywood, whose 3.67-acre lakefront lot at 1020 Palmer Avenue was the kind of parcel Winter Park almost never sees come open, and the late-1930s residence on it — the largest and most ornate home built by the architect James Gamble Rogers II — carried no historic designation to protect it. In a single vote, that future turned.

The facts: Winter Park City Commission, Nov. 11, 2026 — Ordinance 3368-26 approved 4–1 on second reading; property at 1020 Palmer Avenue on Lake Osceola; about 6,200 of the house’s 7,300 square feet to be preserved; owners Steve and Jenny Lockwood; Commissioner Elizabeth Ingram cast the lone no vote.

What the commission actually approved

The commission’s action accomplished two things at once. In a city where lakefront splits are generally prohibited, it amended Winter Park’s comprehensive plan to add a policy permitting the subdivision or lot split of lakefront property that meets specific criteria, unlocking the division of the Merrywood estate into two lots. In return, as the city’s meeting record summarizes the deal, the Lockwood family agreed to preserve 80% of the historic 1939 home through a restrictive covenant recorded against the land, and the covenant itself must come back to the commission for approval.

That final condition carries the real weight of the arrangement. What binds a future buyer is not Wednesday’s goodwill, but the recorded covenant — a deed restriction that, as Bungalower reported, will carry the preservation requirements to whoever owns the property next. The agreement shields approximately 6,200 square feet of the 7,300-square-foot residence, including much of its historic facade.

What preservation does not mean here

Saving most of Merrywood, however, does not leave Merrywood whole. As the Winter Park Voice, which reported the vote first, noted, the owners plan a new primary suite and a three-car garage while demolishing parts of the existing house, among them the original maid’s quarters and an enclosed sunroom. Nor will the preserved square footage count toward the size limit on the lots: under the conditions governing the approval, houses on both lots may reach up to 15,000 square feet, plus accessory structures.

For Commissioner Ingram, the dissent centered on precedent rather than this house alone; she raised concerns that the agreement includes no official historic designation and could set a pattern for other lakefront properties. The shift on the dais was measured instead by Commissioner Warren Lindsey, who had voted no at the first hearing over the summer but reversed his position to vote yes — an arc reflecting how far the negotiation had traveled between the 3–2 first vote in June, when demolition still looked likely, and November.

How the house got its reprieve

The compromise that bridged that divide was built outside the commission chamber. Owens worked with the owners and the architect Michael Wenrich to find terms both sides could accept, the Voice and Bungalower reported, setting up Wednesday’s vote and the brief embrace between Steve Lockwood and Owens that followed. By then, the financial stakes were already steep: the Lockwoods had purchased the property for $15 million in August, according to both outlets’ reporting, after an earlier $10 million offer from the attorney Matt Morgan, who said he intended to preserve the house, failed to carry the day.

For residents, the open question now rests in a legal text rather than a public debate. The restrictive covenant still must return to the commission for approval, and its exact language will decide what “preserved” requires of the next owner, not only this one. Until then, Merrywood stands — an outcome that, back in February, almost nobody in Winter Park expected.

More from the Winter Park hub: this morning’s Citizen record of another Winter Park institution under pressure, Austin’s Coffee cuts its overnight hours; our guide to the resort food festival across the lake corridor, the Swan and Dolphin Food & Wine Classic game plan; and this morning’s Dazzling Nights final buyer’s guide.

Sources & notes

Vote, ordinance number (3368-26, second reading), lot-split policy and covenant-return condition: City of Winter Park commission meeting record for Nov. 11, 2026, as summarised at winterpark.myopenflorida.org, checked Nov. 17, 2026. Vote margin, preserved square footage, owners, purchase price, Owens/Wenrich roles, Ingram and Lindsey positions, and the planned additions/demolitions: Winter Park Voice, “Most of Merrywood Saved After Facing Months of Likely Demolition,” Nov. 11, 2026, and Bungalower, Nov. 13, 2026 — both checked Nov. 17. The June 3–2 first vote and February demolition permit: Winter Park Voice reporting of June–July 2026. No vote count is stated beyond the 4–1 recorded for Ordinance 3368-26. Featured image: file image from related Citizen Winter Park coverage; see that post for its credit.

Filed under · ·

Editor’s Picks

  1. 1NewsEpic Universe Faces Its First Holiday Season
  2. 2ReviewsThe 10 Best Coffee Shops in Orlando
  3. 3TourismMagic Kingdom
  4. 4Top BusinessesHaan Coffee: Mills 50’s Korean-Inflected Roaster Tops Orlando Coffee
  5. 5ReviewsThe 10 Best Attractions & Things To Do in Orlando

Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank

Nora Fitzgerald

Orlando Citizen general-assignment reporter for growth and development features — how the region's building boom lands on the people who already live here.