Orlando After-Midnight Police Fees: Downtown Venues Take Their Case to the Eleventh Circuit on Tuesday
The downtown venues challenging Orlando's after-midnight police-protection fees get their day in the Eleventh Circuit on Tuesday, November 17, when a federal appeals panel in Jacksonville hears argument in 6064 NOA, LLC v. City of Orlando, No. 25-13271 — the case a trial judge dismissed in September 2025.
4 minute read
The legal fight over who pays for late-night policing in downtown Orlando reaches a federal appeals court on Tuesday. The Eleventh Circuit’s official argument calendar lists 6064 NOA, LLC, et al. v. The City of Orlando, et al., No. 25-13271, for argument on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, in the Gerald B. Tjoflat Courtroom in Jacksonville — the appeal by the companies behind seven downtown venues of a trial-court dismissal that left Orlando’s After-Midnight Alcohol Sales permit program in place.
The case began in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida, Orlando Division, as case 6:24-cv-1665-WWB-EJK. The complaint, filed September 13, 2024, was brought by 6064 NOA, LLC — doing business as 64 North, The Patio, Aero Rooftop Bar & Lounge, The Corner and The Social — together with 4654 NOA, LLC, doing business as The Beacham, and Celine Orlando, LLC, doing business as Celine. The defendants are the City of Orlando and Police Chief Eric Smith.
What the venues alleged
The complaint alleged that the permit program violates the venues’ due-process and equal-protection rights under the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments. Under the program — created by Ordinance 2023-17 and codified at section 33.03 of the City Code — a downtown business that wants to sell alcohol between midnight and 2 a.m. in the Downtown Entertainment District must hold a $250 permit, and permit holders with an occupancy of at least 125 must also pay a share of the cost of off-duty Orlando police officers patrolling the district. The plaintiffs put their combined fees at about $591,120 a year, as pleaded, and alleged that the city arbitrarily exempted larger venues — the code exempts civic auditoriums, sports arenas, public lodging establishments and movie theaters — while a small group of nightclubs paid for patrols that benefit the whole district. Those are the plaintiffs’ allegations; no court has adopted them.
The city has defended the program as part of its downtown public-safety effort. When the suit was filed, a city spokesperson declined to comment on the pending litigation. City officials have since said the permit covers only part of what Orlando spends on downtown public safety, and the city has credited its broader downtown effort with a drop in crime — reporting overall downtown crime down 20 percent, with violent crime down 4 percent, compared with the same period a year earlier.
How the case got here
In August 2025 the district court refused the venues’ request to pause the ordinance while the case proceeded. On September 10, 2025, U.S. District Judge Wendy W. Berger dismissed the lawsuit; the dismissal filing, as reported by WKMG News 6, called the complaint an impermissible shotgun pleading that failed to identify its claims with sufficient clarity. The venues appealed, and the Eleventh Circuit has now set the case for argument. The court’s calendar allots argument of up to fifteen minutes per side for the cases on Tuesday’s list; no decision date is set, and a ruling will follow after the argument.
The parallel fight at City Hall
The court case is only half of the pressure on the program. On November 4, 2026, the National Independent Venue Association (NIVA), a national trade group whose members include The Beacham, The Social and Celine, wrote to Mayor Buddy Dyer and the City Council asking the city to suspend the police-protection fee during a comprehensive review. NIVA’s letter, citing city billing records, says Orlando invoiced 39 downtown establishments a combined $4,304,461.60 for off-duty officers from June 2023 through August 2025 — including $330,796.63 billed to The Beacham and $328,952.25 to Celine — and says ten of the 39 establishments have since closed. Those figures are NIVA’s, drawn from the records it cites; the Citizen has not independently audited the city’s billing. A city spokesperson said officials needed more time to review NIVA’s letter before responding to its requests. NIVA’s letter states that its request does not depend on the outcome of the litigation.
What to watch
Tuesday’s argument will not decide the fees on the spot — appellate panels rule in writing, after argument. If the Eleventh Circuit revives the case, the constitutional challenge returns to the district court in Orlando; if it affirms, the dismissal stands and the venues’ remaining routes are rehearing or the U.S. Supreme Court. Either way, permit holders keep paying under the program as it stands unless the city itself suspends the fee, which is the separate question now in front of the City Council.
Reporting notes: case and docket details are from the Middle District of Florida docket report for 6:24-cv-1665-WWB-EJK (Justia) and the Eleventh Circuit’s official oral-argument calendar, Revision 2 (October 15, 2026), both read by this desk on November 15, 2026. The complaint itself is available only through PACER, which this desk does not use on fee; the plaintiffs’ claims above are reported as allegations from the docket and contemporaneous reporting of the filing. NIVA’s billing figures are attributed to its November 4, 2026 letter. More of the Citizen’s coverage of the city’s core is on the Downtown Orlando hub; see also our reporting on the city budget and millage, the downtown SunRail and LYMMO guide, and a Lake Eola weekend.
Photo: Lake Eola Park and the downtown skyline at night (file photo). Photo: Matt Dennison, CC BY 2.0, via Flickr/Openverse; magazine photo grade applied.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank


