The Oasis Club Fee Fight Is Back in Osceola Court
Two homeowners, a putative class of 5,286, and the mandatory club fees every ChampionsGate owner pays: a federal judge has sent the class action back to Osceola Circuit Court. What the complaint alleges, what the developer answers, and what it means for owners now.
4 minute read
Every ChampionsGate homeowner pays for the Oasis Club whether they use it or not. That is the design: the master declaration makes membership mandatory, the fees are collected under the club plan run by Len-CG South, LLC, the Lennar entity that built the community, and the obligation follows the deed. Two homeowners say that design is unlawful — and after a year of fighting over which court should hear them, their case is back where it started, in Osceola County. This report is part of HOA Watch, the ChampionsGate desk’s standing watch on the associations, collected on the ChampionsGate beat.
What the complaint alleges
Steve Schwarz and Brian Heymann sued Len-CG South in the Circuit Court of the Ninth Judicial Circuit in Osceola County, for themselves and as representatives of a putative class the federal court put at 5,286 members — every current and former ChampionsGate homeowner subject to the fees. Their amended complaint, as the federal court summarised it, brings two claims under Florida law: it alleges that the mandatory Oasis Club membership fees violate the Florida Homeowners’ Association Act, and it asks the court to enjoin Len-CG South from collecting the fees in future and to order repayment of the fees already collected. Contemporaneous reporting of the filing (WFTV, drawing on the Orlando Business Journal, March 2025) carried the plaintiffs’ characterisation of an improper “club fee scheme” producing “illegal profits” for the developer. Those are the plaintiffs’ allegations. No court has ruled on them.
The theory is not novel to ChampionsGate. In Avatar Properties v. Gundel (Florida’s Sixth District Court of Appeal, 2023), an appellate court held that developer amenity fees of this kind function as assessments under the Act and may not carry a private profit markup; the Florida Supreme Court left that ruling standing. The Schwarz complaint asks the Osceola court to apply the same logic to the Oasis Club. Len-CG South’s answer on the merits is in its court filings: it has defended the collection throughout and conceded nothing; the question of whether the fees comply with the Act remains entirely open.
A year spent deciding where the case belongs
Len-CG South removed the case to federal court on March 17, 2025, under the Class Action Fairness Act. The federal proceedings then consumed a year without reaching the merits. The original complaint was dismissed without prejudice as a shotgun pleading; the amended complaint proceeded against Len-CG South alone. The homeowners moved to send the case back to Osceola, and that motion turned on arithmetic: under the Act governing federal class-action jurisdiction, the court could — and for larger Florida shares, must — decline the case if enough of the class were Florida citizens.
On March 5, 2026, U.S. District Judge Paul G. Byron granted the remand. Counting homeowners who had claimed the Florida homestead exemption and those registered to vote in Florida, the court found at least 1,813 class members were Florida citizens — more than the one-third threshold of 1,762 — and held that every discretionary factor favoured sending the case home: the claims arise entirely under Florida law, the community and the alleged harm are in Osceola County, and the master declaration itself names the Osceola circuit court as the forum. Len-CG South had opposed remand, arguing among other things that the homeowners had waited too long to seek it; the court rejected that argument, noting the first remand motion came within five months of removal and the delay was spent on the citizenship discovery the motion required. The federal file is closed. A companion federal docket (No. 6:25-cv-465) names Lennar Homes, LLC, LEN OT Holdings, LLC and Lennar Corporation alongside Len-CG South.
What it means for owners now
The remand decides where the case is heard, not who is right. Nothing in the March order changes what any ChampionsGate owner owes today: the fees continue to be collected under the declaration and club plan unless and until a court orders otherwise. What changes is the venue — the case now proceeds in the courthouse in Kissimmee, under Florida procedure, where the merits will finally be reached. The association is not a party: the defendant is the developer entity, and the fees at issue are the club plan’s, not the master association’s assessments — a distinction this desk’s HOA Watch page maps in full, alongside the amenity system’s own funding in Water, Pools and the Oasis Club Economy.
The Citizen presents each side from its own filings, as it does across the beat. This story will be updated as the Osceola case moves; the running docket is kept on the HOA Watch page and in the ChampionsGate archive. For the visitor’s view of the community, see the ChampionsGate area portal.
Sources & notes
Order granting remand, Schwarz & Heymann v. Len-CG South, LLC, No. 6:25-cv-466-PGB-NWH (M.D. Fla., March 5, 2026), Doc. 134, read in full via the court’s public document service — source for the class size (5,286), the citizenship findings (1,813 found; 1,762 threshold), the removal date (March 17, 2025), the claims as summarised from the amended complaint (Doc. 66), the forum-selection clause, the related Country Club action, and the defendant’s waiver argument and its rejection. Dismissal of the original complaint as a shotgun pleading and the amended complaint’s filing: federal docket entries (Docs. 64 and 66) via the public docket listing on Justia Dockets & Filings. Companion docket: Heymann et al v. Lennar Homes, LLC et al, No. 6:25-cv-465 (M.D. Fla.), public docket listing. Filing characterisation (“club fee scheme”): WFTV / Orlando Business Journal, March 29, 2025, attributed to the complaint. Avatar Properties v. Gundel (Fla. 6th DCA 2023): as reported in contemporaneous coverage of the amenity-fee litigation line (Jason Garcia, Seeking Rents, 2025); the decision’s application to ChampionsGate is the plaintiffs’ argument, not a ruling in this case. The state-court case number and post-remand filings are not readable at docket-detail level from public listings as of November 15, 2026; the desk’s weekly sweep tracks them. Nothing here is legal advice.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank


