Mister O1 and the Star Luca: Orlando’s Top-Rated Pizza
Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza takes No. 1 in our Pizza rankings with a Net Score of 98.1 — why it won, and what to get when you go.
2 minute read
Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza is the No. 1 pizza pick in Orlando — not by our say-so, but by the numbers. In Orlando Citizen’s Top Businesses rankings, it posted a Net Score of 98.1, the highest in its category, on a blended 4.9★ drawn from 4,449 public reviews. This is the winner’s profile: why it won, what to get when you go, and the details that make it a Dr. Phillips fixture.
Why it won
Our Net Score blends a business’s public ratings across the review sources we could retrieve — here: Google 4.9★ (4,358), TripAdvisor 4.9★ (91) — weights them by review volume, and then applies Bayesian shrinkage (m = 200) so a handful of five-star reviews can’t outrank a proven track record. Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza cleared a field of 29 ranked businesses in Pizza. That is a clear margin over the No. 2 finisher, V Pizza & Tap Room (96.2). Scores compare only within a category, and the underlying ratings were retrieved November 14, 2026.
What to order
The Star Luca, whose crust points are folded around ricotta, is the signature reviewers name first; the Coffee Paolo (gorgonzola, honey, coffee, spicy salami) is the adventurous order, and the burrata bar and Nutella pizza round out the raves.
The local detail
The crust is a 72-hour fermented dough baked thin and light, and the star-shaped pies are this Dr. Phillips dining room’s calling card on Sand Lake Road.
The essentials
- Find it: 7541 W Sand Lake Rd, Orlando, FL 32819
- Directions: Get directions
- Neighborhood: Dr. Phillips
- Hours: Mon–Thu 11:30 a.m.–10 p.m.; Fri–Sat 11:30 a.m.–11 p.m.; Sun 11:30 a.m.–10 p.m. (as listed in November 2026 — confirm before a special trip)
- Phone: 305-539-0328
- Online: official site
See the full list: The 10 Best Pizza Places in Orlando — every ranked business in this category, with scores.
Share this award:
Share on Facebook · Post on X · ·
🏆 Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza — this award is yours to use
Congratulations on Best Pizza 2026. The badge is free to use on your website, your socials and in your window — all we ask is that it links back to your feature, this page.
⬇ Download the badge (PNG, full size)
Or paste this snippet into your website — it displays the badge and links to your feature:
Photo: kurmanstaff (CC BY), via Openverse. Photo-grade treatment by Orlando Citizen. The photograph is representative of the category, not the business itself.
Part of Orlando Citizen’s Top Businesses in Orlando series. Net Scores are recalculated from fresh public review data each edition.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Related Stories
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank