Chimento’s Spaghetti House: The Dozen Tables Downtown St. Cloud Runs On

Every old Florida town has one restaurant that functions less like a business and more like a piece of civic infrastructure. In St. Cloud, that restaurant is Chimento’s Spaghetti House, at 1110 New York Ave in the middle of the historic downtown — a family-owned Italian room of about a dozen tables where the owners are on site most days and the regulars treat the place as an extension of their own kitchens.

A dozen tables on New York Avenue

The room is small, and that is the point. Chimento’s serves the Italian-American canon — spaghetti and meatballs, baked pastas, calzones, hot subs and hand-built pizzas — in a dining room where a family operation can still see every table. There is no bar scene, no chef’s-counter theater, no reinvention. What there is: red-sauce cooking done with the confidence of repetition, fresh bakes coming out of the kitchen (the house cookie drops have their own local following), and the kind of welcome that makes first-timers understand, about ten minutes in, why people drive here from Daytona and DeBary for a spaghetti house in Osceola County.

The loyalty is the review

Our magazine’s rankings have not reached St. Cloud yet, so we will not dress Chimento’s up in a score it has not earned in our system. What it has earned is harder to fake: repeat business across generations, in a downtown that has watched restaurants come and go around it. The kitchen collaborates with its neighbors, too — joint evenings with downtown bakery and waffle friends pop up on its calendar, the sort of thing that only happens on a main street where the businesses actually like each other. When the downtown runs its holiday window-decorating contest, Chimento’s is in it, asking for votes like everybody else.

Specials, bakes and the neighborhood kitchen

The menu’s center of gravity never moves — spaghetti, meatballs, baked pasta, calzones, subs — but the kitchen plays around the edges in a way only a family place bothers to. The house baker, Stacia, turns out fresh bakes that regulars watch for, and the kitchen steps outside Italy when the calendar gives it an excuse: a chicken and sausage gumbo for Mardi Gras is the kind of special that tells you the cooks are cooking for neighbors, not for a concept deck. Chimento’s also caters, which in practice means half the family gatherings in the older neighborhoods of St. Cloud run on its trays. This is the deeper truth about the place: it is not competing with Orlando’s Italian restaurants, several of which our rankings score highly. It is doing a different job — feeding one town, on one avenue, for years — and doing it well enough that the town has organized its habits around it.

How to do it right

Go on a weekday if you can; a dozen tables fill fast on weekends, and the kitchen keeps daytime-into-evening hours Monday through Saturday, closing Sundays. Order the way the room suggests: a pizza for the table to start — the pies are the thing out-of-towners swear their Italian grandmothers would recognize — then a baked pasta or the spaghetti the house is named for. Save room if there is a fresh bake on the counter. Afterwards, walk it off the way downtown intends: New York Avenue is the heart of a National Register historic district, and our downtown guide maps the murals, the 1927 Hunter Arms Hotel and the G.A.R. Memorial Hall within a few blocks. Theatre in the Cloud, the community stage, sits just around the block, which makes Chimento’s the natural pre-show dinner. For the wider picture — steakhouses, barbecue, the lakefront — see where to eat in St. Cloud, and find the downtown cluster pinned on the Orlando Top Spots Map.

Filed under Downtown · Italian Food · Pizza · Restaurants · St. Cloud

Related Stories

ReviewsWhere to Eat in Pine Castle: The Orange Avenue PatternReviewsWhere to Eat in Union Park: The Colonial Corridor Feeds ItReviewsWhere to Eat in Azalea Park: The Corridors Do the Cooking

Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank