The Greenery Creamery: The Church Street Shop That Made Vegan Ice Cream the Main Event
Orlando's first artisanal ice cream boutique, at 420 E. Church Street since 2018 — small-batch dairy, a coconut-and-soy vegan menu with a cult following, and No. 3 in our ice cream rankings at 92.1.
3 minute read
Every neighborhood gets the ice cream shop it deserves, and South Eola got a serious one. The Greenery Creamery, at 420 East Church Street, Unit 112, bills itself as Orlando’s first artisanal ice cream boutique — and since opening in 2018 it has made the case scoop by scoop, building a following on small batches, real ingredients and a vegan program that is the headline rather than the footnote. In the magazine’s rankings it stands No. 3 among Orlando’s ice cream shops, with a Net Score of 92.1; the category winner is Sampaguita, but downtown, this is the cone that counts.
Made properly, in small batches
The shop’s method is the old one. Ice cream is handcrafted in small batches for freshness and control; the dairy base is pasteurized in-house and built on milk from local Florida grass-fed cows; ingredients are locally sourced and organic when possible; and the shop commits to no additives like stabilizers or preservatives — fresh, real ingredients only. You can taste the discipline in the classics — butter pecan, cookies and cream, rocky road — but the regulars are here for the flavors nobody else in town is making.
The vegan side is the main event
Most ice cream shops treat dairy-free as an apology. The Greenery Creamery treats it as a second menu, built on coconut and soy, and it is where the signature lives: Black Ash Coconut, the shop’s calling card, served in a black ash coconut waffle cone with rose crystals if you’re doing it properly. Around it rotate the flavors with the cult followings — ube in several forms, blueberry lavender, an aged Earl Grey steeped in Florida milk that the shop counts among its most popular, and a rolling cast of seasonal specials that regulars track the way other people track concert announcements. The dairy case keeps pace — gochujang caramel has appeared; triple-C and ube brownie have their devotees — and the counter will happily let you taste across the divide before you commit.
The specials culture
Regulars plan around the rotating specials the way other people plan around farmers markets. The shop builds limited runs around seasons and ideas — an autumn tarot series, for instance, dealt out flavors like The Sun (salted caramel with cinnamon apple sorbet), The Magician (a vegan black cocoa brownie batter with peanut butter fudge) and The High Priestess (the beloved Earl Grey, dressed up) — and announces them to a following that shows up before they sell through. It is a small shop running a big shop’s flavor calendar, and it keeps the case unpredictable in a way the classics alone never could. If a special is on when you visit, the rule is simple: taste it first, decide second.
Beyond the cone
The format range is wider than the storefront suggests: pints to go, milkshakes and floats, cookies and fudge brownies, ice cream cookie sandwiches, and custom ice cream cakes — including gluten-free and dairy-free builds that have made the shop a lifeline for allergy households celebrating birthdays. The room itself leans into the name: greenery everywhere, a plant-shop calm a block from the lake’s noise. Hours run from noon daily, with later closes on Friday and Saturday nights — timed, intentionally or not, for the post-dinner lake lap.
The South Eola ritual
The downtown shop is the original; the Greenery Creamery has since added Sanford and a location near the Florida Mall, but the Church Street counter is the one woven into a neighborhood routine. It goes like this: a lap of the lake, dinner somewhere on the South Eola row (our eating guide sorts the options), then a cone eaten walking back toward the water as the fountain lights come up. On Sundays the sequence starts at the farmers market instead. Either way, the Greenery Creamery is where the neighborhood’s day lands — proof that the shortest distance between a good park and a good evening is about one block, with ice cream at the end of it. Find it on the Top Spots Map.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Related Stories
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank
