Caribbean Supercenter: The Market, the Kitchen and the Patty Run on West Colonial

Every great food neighborhood has a place that explains it, and in Pine Hills that place is Caribbean Supercenter, at 5111 W. Colonial Drive. It describes itself simply — a West Indian supermarket with everything you need from the Caribbean — and that undersells the arrangement. This is a full Caribbean grocery and a working kitchen under one roof, on the southern edge of Pine Hills, and the two halves feed each other: you shop the ingredients, then you taste what they are for.

The kitchen first, if you are hungry

Regulars will tell you to eat before you shop, and they are right. The kitchen’s reputation rests on a short list of Caribbean standards done with conviction: patties with a proper flaky crust, oxtail stew cooked down until the gravy goes glossy, jerk chicken with real char and heat, and curry chicken that tastes of a home kitchen rather than a steam table. These are the dishes the phase research for this hub flagged by name, and they are the dishes the neighborhood orders on repeat. Portions follow the takeout logic of West Colonial Drive — this is food built to travel home to Pine Hills, Metrowest and the west side, and to feed more people than you planned.

Then the market, which is the point

With lunch handled, walk the aisles. A West Indian supermarket in a neighborhood with large Jamaican, Haitian, Trinidadian and wider Caribbean communities cannot afford to be decorative; it has to stock what home cooks actually ask for. That means the produce and pantry of the islands — the roots, peppers, plantains, canned and jarred staples, seasonings and drinks that mainstream Orlando groceries either skip or scatter. For a cook from the diaspora, this is a weekly shop. For a cook from anywhere else, it is an education: the raw materials of the food you just ate, available by the bag and bottle, with staff and fellow shoppers who know what to do with them.

That dual role — market and kitchen — is exactly why Caribbean Supercenter anchors our Where to Eat in Pine Hills roundup. Plenty of Orlando restaurants cook Caribbean food well. Far fewer sit inside the supply chain of the community that food comes from. When the same roof covers the grocery run and the oxtail, the cooking stays honest, because its toughest critics are pushing carts ten feet away.

Where it sits, and what is around it

The Supercenter stands on West Colonial just west of Pine Hills Road, at the busiest crossroads in the neighborhood. A few blocks west is Golden Krust’s Jamaican bakery and grill; across the intersection, the paifang of Orlando Chinatown fronts Enson Market and more than 60 Asian businesses. Park once on this stretch of Colonial and you can eat your way through three diasporas before your ice cream melts — though for the full plaza walk, see our guide to Orlando Chinatown. The Orlando Top Spots Map shows how tight this cluster really is.

How to do the Supercenter run

Go at lunch, when the kitchen is in full swing. Order the oxtail if it is your first visit — it is the dish that tells you whether a Caribbean kitchen is serious, and this one is — and a patty for the road, because everyone does. Then shop slowly. Pick up the pepper sauce, the plantains, the drink you have never tried. Ask a question if you have one; this is a neighborhood market, and questions are normal here. Pine Hills has no ranked restaurants yet, and the Supercenter would probably shrug at the idea. It has something better than a ranking: a parking lot full of people who grew up on this food and keep coming back for it.

Filed under Caribbean Supercenter · Jamaican Food · Markets · Pine Hills · West Colonial Drive

Related Stories

ReviewsWhere to Eat in Pine Castle: The Orange Avenue PatternReviewsWhere to Eat in Union Park: The Colonial Corridor Feeds ItReviewsWhere to Eat in Azalea Park: The Corridors Do the Cooking

Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank