Colonialtown, Explained: Two Neighborhoods, One Drive, Zero Tourist Traps
Split by East Colonial Drive into an 1883-platted historic south and a 1911 Highland Grove north, Colonialtown hides its best tables in its houses and its services along the corridor. The complete guide to Orlando's most residential neighborhood.
3 minute read
Most Orlando neighborhoods have a main street. Colonialtown has a dividing line. East Colonial Drive — State Road 50 — cuts the neighborhood in two, and the two halves have been living different lives ever since: Colonialtown North above the Drive, Colonialtown South below it, each a grid of early-20th-century subdivisions that filled in with bungalows, duplexes and revival-style houses while the commercial corridor grew up between them. Learn that split and you understand the whole place.
Two plats, one name
The south side is the elder. Colonialtown South reaches back to a subdivision platted in 1883, with its largest area developed starting in 1913 and much of its housing built during the 1920s Florida land boom and the years between the Depression and World War II. In 2000 the city designated Colonialtown South a local historic district, which is why its brick streets and live oaks still shelter such a intact run of Craftsman bungalows, Minimal Traditional houses and Colonial, Mediterranean, Mission, Prairie and Tudor Revival details. North of the Drive, Colonialtown North was first platted in 1911 as Highland Grove, and it runs a little looser — bright-painted cottages and new infill beside the older stock, no historic-district rulebook. Same bones, different temperament.
A residential neighborhood that eats at its edges
Colonialtown has almost no commercial interior, and that is its charm. The destination tables hide in the residential streets: Maxine’s on Shine, a Michelin Guide selection run by Kirt and Maxine Earhart out of a house on Shine Avenue, holds the neighborhood’s brunch crown, while Il Pescatore does old-school, family-run Italian on Primrose Drive. Everything else lines the edges. Along East Colonial Drive itself runs the everyday corridor — barbershop, spa, nail salon, gym — that we map in our Colonial Drive corridor piece. At the western edge, plainly labeled, sits Mills 50, the Orlando Main Street district at Mills Avenue and Colonial Drive, with its Vietnamese restaurants and independent shops. Colonialtown residents treat it as their kitchen annex, and visitors should too — just know whose portal it belongs to.
The green south rim
What Colonialtown lacks in storefronts it makes up in green. Along its southern rim, Mayor Carl T. Langford Park and Dickson Azalea Park form a shaded, creek-cut pair — playgrounds and courts in one, a 1926 bridge and azalea ravines in the other — and Festival Park’s 16 open acres wait just east on Robinson Street. We walk all three in our Colonialtown parks guide. It means a Colonialtown day sequences itself: a park in the morning, a corridor errand at midday, a house-turned-restaurant at night.
How the rankings see it
Our Top Businesses rankings capture the split personality honestly: seven ranked entries in all. The two destination tables score in the low nineties — Maxine’s at No. 5 for brunch with a Net Score of 90.9, Il Pescatore at No. 6 for Italian with 91.9 — while the corridor services score higher still, led by Orlando Power Yoga just south on South Street at No. 3 for yoga and Pilates with 97.4. Every one of them is plotted on the Orlando Top Spots Map, and our where to eat in Colonialtown roundup and local’s weekend guide put them in visiting order.
The verdict
Come to Colonialtown the way locals use it: not as a destination strip but as a neighborhood with excellent edges. Walk the brick streets of the historic district in the golden hour, book the house on Shine Avenue for dinner, and let the Drive — loud, useful, unglamorous — handle everything else. It has been dividing and feeding this neighborhood for a century. It is very good at both jobs.
Best for: travelers who want the Orlando locals actually live in, architecture walkers, and anyone booking one great neighborhood dinner instead of a theme-park reservation.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Related Stories
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank