Old Town, New Design: Mount Dora’s History Museum, Donnelly House and the Modernism Museum
A firehouse-turned-history museum, an 1893 Queen Anne landmark and a downtown museum of Memphis Group design: Mount Dora's three small museums tell one big story about what the town keeps, and what it collects.
3 minute read
Most small towns get one museum, in a building nobody else wanted. Mount Dora has three within a few downtown blocks, and together they explain the town better than any single exhibit: one for its own past, one for the house that symbolizes it, and one — unexpectedly — for the future the twentieth century imagined.
Mount Dora History Museum
The Mount Dora History Museum, run by the Mount Dora Historical Society, occupies the old city firehouse and jail building downtown — the kind of adaptive reuse the town does instinctively. Inside, the exhibits cover the settlement story: the town first named Royellou in 1880 after the postmaster’s children, renamed for the lake, incorporated in 1921 with John P. Donnelly as its first mayor. Photographs, artifacts and period rooms trace the citrus, railroad and winter-tourism eras that built the streets you are standing on. It is a small museum with a short visit time, which makes it the right first stop of a downtown day: an hour here recalibrates everything you see afterward, from the Lakeside Inn of 1883 to the shopfronts of Donnelly Street.
The naming story alone is worth the visit. The settlement’s first official name, in 1880, was Royellou — a compression of Roy, Ella and Lou, the three children of postmaster R. C. Tremain, whose family name also survives on Tremain Street and the Lakeside Inn’s tavern. The town took the lake’s name, Mount Dora, in 1883 — the same year the Alexander House opened — and the museum is where those threads are kept straight, alongside the citrus-grove and railroad decades that turned a lakeside settlement into a winter resort town. Docent-led context varies, but even a self-guided pass through the photographs reorders your sense of downtown: half the storefronts you walked past turn out to be in the pictures.
The Donnelly House
John P. Donnelly’s own house is the district’s architectural postcard: built in 1893 for the Pittsburgh businessman who became the town’s first mayor, it is a Queen Anne Victorian with a turret, wraparound porch and ornate woodwork, standing near the park that also carries his name. Donnelly Park, at 530 N Donnelly St and dating to 1924, is the historic district’s central green and the stage for concerts and festival events. Even if you only see the house from the sidewalk, it anchors the downtown walk in our Mount Dora guide — the mayor’s house, the mayor’s park and the mayor’s era, all in one block.
The Modernism Museum
Then the story jumps a century. The Modernism Museum, at 145 E 4th Ave, holds a major collection of Studio Craft and modernist design — work by makers such as Wharton Esherick and George Nakashima, and exhibitions that have featured the Memphis Group, the 1980s Milan collective whose bold, playful furniture still startles in a Victorian streetscape; past displays have included pieces from David Bowie’s own Memphis collection. The museum’s shoppe sits across the street, and its orbit extends to the table: 1921 Mount Dora, next door at 142 E 4th Ave, displays rotating art in its dining rooms. Check the museum’s current exhibition and opening pattern before you go — hours run on a Thursday-to-Sunday pattern in recent listings.
How the three fit together
Do them in chronological order and the town reads like an argument: the History Museum says this is who we were, the Donnelly House says this is what we built, and the Modernism Museum says this is what we collect now. It is also, not coincidentally, the logic of the antique shops around them. Find all three on the Orlando Top Spots Map.
Photo: Ebyabe, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Related Stories
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank