Where to Eat in Sanford: German Beer Halls, a Southern Bistro and a Train-Station Food Hall
Hollerbach's, The Tennessee Truffle, Henry's Depot, The District and the Colonial Room — Sanford's essential tables, all within a few brick blocks of First Street.
3 minute read
For a city of Sanford’s size, the eating is absurdly good — and almost all of it sits within a few brick blocks of First Street. This is the working shortlist for Sanford: the German institution, the tiny Southern bistro, the train-station food hall, the special-occasion room and the diner locals have claimed for decades. Plot them all on our Top Spots Map before you go.
Hollerbach’s German Restaurant — the anchor
At 205 East 1st Street, Hollerbach’s has been Sanford’s gravitational centre since 2001: a full German beer hall and biergarten serving Wiener schnitzel, Jägerschnitzel, sauerbraten and giant pretzels, with imported German beers on tap and live entertainment in the room. It is loud, warm and built for groups — the place out-of-towners get taken to, and the place locals still choose for birthdays. Its companion German Market around the corner on Magnolia Avenue adds a bakery and deli counter. We profile the whole operation in Hollerbach’s and Sanford’s German quarter.
The Tennessee Truffle — small room, serious cooking
The Tennessee Truffle, at 125 West 1st Street, is the opposite proposition: a small downtown bistro making everything in house, taking Southern staples and rebuilding them with produce from Central Florida farms. It ranks No. 3 in our best brunch spots in Orlando rankings with a Net Score of 91.6, on the strength of a Saturday brunch built around biscuits and gravy and shrimp and grits — and its few dinner services a week are just as sought after. The category’s winner is profiled in our Hampton Social winner feature. Book ahead; the room is small and the town knows it.
Henry’s Depot — the group-pleaser
Can’t agree? Go to 212 West 1st Street. Henry’s Depot is a culinary collective inside the story of Sanford’s original railroad site: multiple independent food vendors under one historic roof, an old-Florida-themed bar called The Basin, a big patio, and live entertainment. It ranks No. 5 in our best food halls in Orlando rankings with a Net Score of 91.2. Everyone orders what they actually want, nobody compromises, and the building itself — freight-depot bones, period signage — does the decorating. More in our Henry’s Depot profile.
The District — the date-night room
On West 2nd Street, The District Eatery Tap & Barrel is Sanford’s grown-up dinner: hand-crafted New American cooking, craft beer and artisanal cocktails in a rustic room that leans into the historic district’s industrial architecture. It is the reservation to make when the occasion matters and driving into Orlando feels like a chore — Sanford’s own answer to the special-occasion restaurant, two blocks from the lake.
The Colonial Room — the local’s breakfast
Every real Florida town has one diner that functions as its living room, and Sanford’s is the Colonial Room at 105 East 1st Street: family-owned, down-home Southern cooking, breakfast and lunch, biscuits in sausage gravy and a country-store entrance you walk through to reach your table. It is inexpensive, unpretentious and exactly where to start a Saturday before the farmers market on the same street.
And for dessert, the German bakery
Build one habit into any Sanford eating day: finish at the Hollerbach’s German Market bakery case on Magnolia Avenue. The restaurant’s companion market bakes in-house — breads, cakes and seasonal specials — and a slice of Black Forest cake or a bag of pastries for the next morning is the town’s most portable souvenir. It is also the tell of a serious food town: the best meal in Sanford comes with its own bakery next door.
How to choose
First visit: Hollerbach’s, because nothing else in Central Florida does what it does. Food people: the Truffle, booked ahead. A group with opinions: Henry’s Depot. A date: The District, then a lakefront walk. A local’s morning: the Colonial Room, early. However you land, you are eating within a few blocks of the water — finish with the RiverWalk and call it a Sanford day.
Photo: Ebyabe, CC BY 2.5, via Wikimedia Commons.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Related Stories
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank
