Audubon Park’s Sweet Tooth: Half-Pound Cookies, Flights and Brioche Donuts
Gideon's original counter, Kelly's six-flavour flight, The Salty's guava-and-cheese donut and taiyaki inside the market — Corrine Drive is Orlando's dessert corridor. Pace yourself. Nobody does.
3 minute read
Most neighbourhoods have a dessert place. Audubon Park has a dessert corridor: within a few Corrine Drive blocks you can eat a cookie that weighs almost half a pound, a six-flavour ice cream flight, a brioche donut filled with guava and cheese, a fish-shaped taiyaki and handcrafted French-style chocolates — and three of those stops sit in our citywide rankings. This is the sweet map of the Garden District, in the order a serious person might attempt it. Pace yourself. Nobody does, but pace yourself anyway.
The heavyweight: Gideon’s Bakehouse, the original
Gideon’s Bakehouse inside East End Market (3201 Corrine Dr) is where the phenomenon started in October 2016, before Disney Springs, before the lines became folklore — one employee, an $800 budget and a chocolate chip cookie recipe its founder had spent years perfecting. The cookies are handmade in small batches, weigh almost half a pound and take many hours to prepare; the East End shop ranks No. 5 among Orlando bakeries in our rankings (90.6; bakery rankings) and is the Gideon’s that accepts preorders, which is the single most useful fact a local can know. Cake slices rotate, limited monthly flavours reward regulars, and the correct move is one cookie now, one for tomorrow. The bakery category’s winner feature is here.
The flight: Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream
Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream (3114 Corrine Dr) is the neighbourhood scoop shop in the best sense: founded in 2014 by Kelly and Scott Seidl, family-owned, everything churned in-house, with a case that mixes Kelly’s Originals — Mexican Chocolate, spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg and allspice, is the connoisseur’s pick — against monthly featured flavours that turn the shop into a subscription you walk to. It ranks No. 9 for ice cream in Orlando (89.5; ice cream rankings). The signature move is the Flight: six flavours, chosen by you, which converts indecision from a flaw into a strategy. Ice cream pies, sundaes and shakes fill out the menu, non-dairy flavours rotate, and there are dog pops for the Corrine Drive canine majority. Our ice cream category’s winner feature is here.
The donut run: The Salty
The Salty Donut (3025 Corrine Dr), No. 7 in our bakery rankings at 88.8, is Audubon Park’s morning anchor: chef-driven brioche donuts — the Brown Butter & Salt cake donut and the Guava & Cheese are the two to start with — seasonal specials that locals track the way others track sports, and a serious coffee program (the Cinnamon Cereal Milk Latte has its own following). It opens early, the patio fills with dogs and laptops, and it is the correct first stop before a Corrine Drive shopping run. More on the morning circuit in our breakfast and coffee guide.
The market-hall bench
East End Market hides two more sweet stops behind the headline cookie. Wafu makes taiyaki — the traditional Japanese fish-shaped waffle, sweet or savoury fillings — with soft serve, street-food style. ÔBON Chocolatier handcrafts chocolates with a French chocolatier’s discipline, the box-of-chocolates gift this neighbourhood actually gives. Add a La Femme du Fromage cheese course if your sweet tooth has a savoury twin, and the market alone covers dessert four ways; our full market profile is here.
The verdict
If you only have one afternoon: Gideon’s preorder in hand, a Kelly’s flight on the pavement outside, and a Salty donut saved for the morning you will inevitably come back. Audubon Park’s sweets are all pinned on the Top Spots Map, and the full street is walked in our Corrine Drive guide. Sugar is not a course here. It is a neighbourhood institution with several addresses.
Orlando Citizen by email
The weekly edition, in your inbox
One email, every Saturday: the week’s edition of Orlando Citizen — the week’s stories, rankings and winners, gathered in one place. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Related Stories
Editor’s Picks
Spotted an error? Tell us — corrections · How we rank